Claim at v1.1.0

canopy-cools

e47c78431c7dbf5ab1c56b28935d969b3b629e902b85e1317ac564286b4e5f4e

Data

{
  "bridgeNote": null,
  "chain": [
    "trees and greenery",
    "local temperature"
  ],
  "city": {
    "ci": [
      -0.66,
      -0.06
    ],
    "n": 42,
    "p": 0.00609,
    "partialRhoPoverty": -0.397,
    "q": 0.06699,
    "rho": -0.416,
    "unit": "UHF42 neighborhood",
    "x": "tree canopy cover (%)",
    "y": "daytime summer surface temperature (°F)"
  },
  "inputs": [
    {
      "collection": "nyc/environment-health",
      "collectionId": "702c055e-4d37-4c6d-a769-0ebe4ea89307",
      "label": "tree canopy cover (%)",
      "period": "2014",
      "query": null,
      "recordIds": [
        "708:UHF42:101:41",
        "708:UHF42:102:41",
        "708:UHF42:103:41",
        "708:UHF42:104:41",
        "708:UHF42:105:41",
        "708:UHF42:106:41",
        "708:UHF42:107:41",
        "708:UHF42:201:41",
        "708:UHF42:202:41",
        "708:UHF42:203:41",
        "708:UHF42:204:41",
        "708:UHF42:205:41",
        "708:UHF42:206:41",
        "708:UHF42:207:41",
        "708:UHF42:208:41",
        "708:UHF42:209:41",
        "708:UHF42:210:41",
        "708:UHF42:211:41",
        "708:UHF42:301:41",
        "708:UHF42:302:41",
        "708:UHF42:303:41",
        "708:UHF42:304:41",
        "708:UHF42:305:41",
        "708:UHF42:306:41",
        "708:UHF42:307:41",
        "708:UHF42:308:41",
        "708:UHF42:309:41",
        "708:UHF42:310:41",
        "708:UHF42:401:41",
        "708:UHF42:402:41",
        "708:UHF42:403:41",
        "708:UHF42:404:41",
        "708:UHF42:405:41",
        "708:UHF42:406:41",
        "708:UHF42:407:41",
        "708:UHF42:408:41",
        "708:UHF42:409:41",
        "708:UHF42:410:41",
        "708:UHF42:501:41",
        "708:UHF42:502:41",
        "708:UHF42:503:41",
        "708:UHF42:504:41"
      ],
      "recordType": "Observation",
      "role": "city",
      "semver": "v1.0.0",
      "version": "ulv3:cd96b9507b2f4e362ac4d7dbbf40a8c00ef01cc7787bb7d5d7758951e3c2352e"
    },
    {
      "collection": "nyc/environment-health",
      "collectionId": "702c055e-4d37-4c6d-a769-0ebe4ea89307",
      "label": "daytime summer surface temperature (°F)",
      "period": "2018",
      "query": null,
      "recordIds": [
        "688:UHF42:101:47",
        "688:UHF42:102:47",
        "688:UHF42:103:47",
        "688:UHF42:104:47",
        "688:UHF42:105:47",
        "688:UHF42:106:47",
        "688:UHF42:107:47",
        "688:UHF42:201:47",
        "688:UHF42:202:47",
        "688:UHF42:203:47",
        "688:UHF42:204:47",
        "688:UHF42:205:47",
        "688:UHF42:206:47",
        "688:UHF42:207:47",
        "688:UHF42:208:47",
        "688:UHF42:209:47",
        "688:UHF42:210:47",
        "688:UHF42:211:47",
        "688:UHF42:301:47",
        "688:UHF42:302:47",
        "688:UHF42:303:47",
        "688:UHF42:304:47",
        "688:UHF42:305:47",
        "688:UHF42:306:47",
        "688:UHF42:307:47",
        "688:UHF42:308:47",
        "688:UHF42:309:47",
        "688:UHF42:310:47",
        "688:UHF42:401:47",
        "688:UHF42:402:47",
        "688:UHF42:403:47",
        "688:UHF42:404:47",
        "688:UHF42:405:47",
        "688:UHF42:406:47",
        "688:UHF42:407:47",
        "688:UHF42:408:47",
        "688:UHF42:409:47",
        "688:UHF42:410:47",
        "688:UHF42:501:47",
        "688:UHF42:502:47",
        "688:UHF42:503:47",
        "688:UHF42:504:47"
      ],
      "recordType": "Observation",
      "role": "city",
      "semver": "v1.0.0",
      "version": "ulv3:cd96b9507b2f4e362ac4d7dbbf40a8c00ef01cc7787bb7d5d7758951e3c2352e"
    },
    {
      "collection": "nyc/environment-health",
      "collectionId": "702c055e-4d37-4c6d-a769-0ebe4ea89307",
      "label": "residents below poverty (%)",
      "period": "2019-23",
      "query": null,
      "recordIds": [
        "221:UHF42:101:348",
        "221:UHF42:102:348",
        "221:UHF42:103:348",
        "221:UHF42:104:348",
        "221:UHF42:105:348",
        "221:UHF42:106:348",
        "221:UHF42:107:348",
        "221:UHF42:201:348",
        "221:UHF42:202:348",
        "221:UHF42:203:348",
        "221:UHF42:204:348",
        "221:UHF42:205:348",
        "221:UHF42:206:348",
        "221:UHF42:207:348",
        "221:UHF42:208:348",
        "221:UHF42:209:348",
        "221:UHF42:210:348",
        "221:UHF42:211:348",
        "221:UHF42:301:348",
        "221:UHF42:302:348",
        "221:UHF42:303:348",
        "221:UHF42:304:348",
        "221:UHF42:305:348",
        "221:UHF42:306:348",
        "221:UHF42:307:348",
        "221:UHF42:308:348",
        "221:UHF42:309:348",
        "221:UHF42:310:348",
        "221:UHF42:401:348",
        "221:UHF42:402:348",
        "221:UHF42:403:348",
        "221:UHF42:404:348",
        "221:UHF42:405:348",
        "221:UHF42:406:348",
        "221:UHF42:407:348",
        "221:UHF42:408:348",
        "221:UHF42:409:348",
        "221:UHF42:410:348",
        "221:UHF42:501:348",
        "221:UHF42:502:348",
        "221:UHF42:503:348",
        "221:UHF42:504:348"
      ],
      "recordType": "Observation",
      "role": "city",
      "semver": "v1.0.0",
      "version": "ulv3:cd96b9507b2f4e362ac4d7dbbf40a8c00ef01cc7787bb7d5d7758951e3c2352e"
    },
    {
      "collection": "system/public-graph",
      "collectionId": "107b4da5-717f-4b99-880e-4b1773d22096",
      "label": null,
      "period": null,
      "query": null,
      "recordIds": [
        "5MyMfP6zz4",
        "6ji3m5ql1p",
        "OSMf7TO1G6",
        "akzMjXQFP3",
        "k5ZAUU8Khp",
        "sH7Acc7aXm",
        "wWjmNIy3IW",
        "xrQRs12Dc0"
      ],
      "recordType": "Association",
      "role": "research",
      "semver": "v1.0.0",
      "version": "ulv3:cf73c4f9d7452909fa2b796791feac01a99de09eeb21b277744b0e5e96f272e0"
    }
  ],
  "kind": "direct",
  "research": {
    "agreement": 0.57,
    "direction": "mixed",
    "dois": [
      "10.1007/s11356-022-23445-3",
      "10.1098/rsta.2015.0219",
      "10.1109/agro-geoinformatics.2012.6311657",
      "10.1117/12.2324740",
      "10.1117/12.2573921",
      "10.21660/2020.75.23161",
      "10.3390/s19235239"
    ],
    "evidenceFit": 0.114,
    "excludedAfterReview": 0,
    "findings": 8,
    "nycStudies": 0,
    "studies": 7
  },
  "resolution": "The studies disagree. New York's data take a side: where tree canopy cover (%) is higher, daytime summer surface temperature (°F) is lower (ρ -0.42, n 42).",
  "settle": "Street-level air temperature sensors next to canopy measurements.",
  "title": "Tree canopy cools neighborhoods",
  "triage": [
    "research mixed",
    "population mismatch"
  ],
  "verdict": "contested"
}

History in this collection

  1. addedv1.0.0Nov 14, 2026this version