Claim at v1.2.0

graph-triad-cold-asthma-absence

b03eb5cdc06d86535a5a970bdea154f2fd01bda2027f8e28345e759e6345b2f7

Data

{
  "has_outcome": true,
  "kind": "bridge",
  "lineage": {
    "audit": "docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json",
    "class": "a",
    "class_meaning": "exposure or treatment only, not the outcome",
    "classes": [
      "a"
    ],
    "early_sources": [
      {
        "class": "a",
        "dataset": "GHCN-Daily v3 (NCEI), doi:10.7289/V5D21VHZ",
        "evidence": "Daily temperature (GHCN-Daily) is the exposure, not the outcome. It is weather, fetched for earlier heat claims and reused.",
        "fetched": "2026-11-12T20:23:55-05:00"
      }
    ]
  },
  "outcome": "graph-triad-cold-asthma-absence",
  "prereg_branch": {
    "name": "prereg/graph-triad-cold-asthma-absence",
    "sha": "c6ab90335fd6d2fbaaad10cca44c749b4474c8ca"
  },
  "prior": 0.55,
  "registered_at": "2026-11-12T22:51:37-0500",
  "registrant": "claude (graph triads study)",
  "registration": {
    "alternatives": [
      "Temperature affects attendance directly (discomfort, travel, classrooms without air conditioning, families' choices), not through asthma; a ratio far above the composed interval indicates this.",
      "Calendar: late June is hot and attendance falls at the end of the year; winter cold coincides with influenza season and snow. Week-of-year and school-year effects and the snow indicator address this in part; influenza is not controlled.",
      "Citywide aggregation hides schools that close or report late on extreme days; the exclusions address this in part.",
      "The asthma links come from hospital admissions in Hong Kong, Hefei, Lanzhou and Florida and from 92 children in Minnesota; none is a New York school population."
    ],
    "chain": [
      "temperature -> asthma exacerbation (graph)",
      "asthma -> days absent (graph)"
    ],
    "composition": {
      "composed_ratio_lo_median_hi": [
        1.0007778837133046,
        1.0072685309733118,
        1.0172716526590189
      ],
      "discrimination": {
        "D_expected": 0.22972714718184198,
        "advice": "the test cannot separate the chain from no effect; find a larger contrast or a more precise endpoint",
        "combined_se": 0.016544124086493393,
        "discriminates": false,
        "endpoint_se": 0.016,
        "p_null_passes": 0.9330052811874541,
        "z_null_if_chain_true": 0.4792985991861879
      },
      "exponent": {
        "mean": 0.0156,
        "meaning": "share of pupil absences attributable to asthma = prevalence U(0.08, 0.15) x excess days 2.21 (1.41-3.01) / mean days absent U(13, 20); prevalence and mean days absent are the registrant's assumptions, not graph findings",
        "sd": 0.0045
      },
      "link": {
        "estimate": 1.64,
        "hi": 2.54,
        "lo": 1.06,
        "pubmed_id": "35817164"
      },
      "method": "kit.bridge.compose, log RR(absence) = share x log RR(asthma exacerbation), 20000 draws, seed 1"
    },
    "disclosure": "No attendance data had been queried by this project before registration (no file for these datasets in data/cache/socrata; only the catalog's column names were read). The Central Park temperature series had been used by earlier claims, and the counts of exposed days (116 of 843 hot-season weekdays, 145 of 838 cold-season weekdays) were computed from it before registration. The registrant knows in general that New York attendance falls in late June and on snow days. A web search summary of Keivabu 2024 was read before registration.",
    "graph_evidence": [
      {
        "concepts": "temperature family (hot, temperature, air temperature) - asthma",
        "direction": "+ for heat in the hot season and + for cold in the cold season; the 32 positive and 8 negative rows mix both, and include heaters and exhaled temperature",
        "n_findings": 40,
        "n_studies": 24,
        "pubmed_ids": [
          "35817164",
          "34555607",
          "39251927",
          "36240934"
        ],
        "relationship_id": [
          "4FaXcuNJRt|EAshH_Ko3h",
          "EAshH_Ko3h|4FaXcuNJRt",
          "dINFs04idR|EAshH_Ko3h"
        ],
        "summary": "cold (5th percentile of temperature) and childhood asthma hospitalisation, RR 1.64 (1.06-2.54) on days with lower PM2.5, Hefei 2013-2016; also low temperature RR 1.20 (1.15-1.26), Lanzhou (PMID 39251927), and 1.10 (1.05-1.15) in adults, Hong Kong (PMID 36240934)"
      },
      {
        "concepts": "asthma - school attendance",
        "direction": "+ (more days absent)",
        "n_findings": 1,
        "n_studies": 31,
        "pubmed_ids": [
          "11487757"
        ],
        "relationship_id": [
          "EAshH_Ko3h|_l4tNqo_PI"
        ],
        "summary": "children with asthma had 2.21 (1.41-3.01) more days absent per year than matched children without asthma, Rochester, Minnesota (abstract read; the relationship record lists 31 studies but the API returns one finding)"
      },
      {
        "concepts": "temperature family - school attendance",
        "direction": null,
        "n_findings": 0,
        "n_studies": 0,
        "pubmed_ids": [],
        "relationship_id": null,
        "summary": "no direct finding in the graph for hot, temperature, air temperature, surface temperature, heat wave or urban heat island with school attendance (two findings from two studies with absenteeism)"
      }
    ],
    "id": "graph-triad-cold-asthma-absence",
    "kind": "bridge",
    "literature": [
      {
        "citation": "Keivabu RC. Temperature and school absences: evidence from England. Population and Environment 2024",
        "doi": "10.1007/s11111-024-00448-5",
        "finding": "hot days increase absences in English schools; cold days show no substantive effect. Not in the graph. Read as a search summary only, not the paper."
      }
    ],
    "plan": "Unit: school day, citywide, school years 2006-07 to 2018-19. Outcome: log(sum of absent / sum of enrolled) over all schools by date, from NYC Open Data daily attendance by school (xwxx-rnki, wpqj-3buw, pffu-gbfi, 3y5p-x48f, x3bb-kg5j), aggregated in SoQL. Exclusions fixed now: weekends; days whose citywide enrolment is below 80% of that school year's median; days with an absence rate above 30%. Arm: school days in December, January and February. Exposure: Central Park TMAX <= 0.0 C on the same day (NOAA GHCN-Daily USW00094728). Model: OLS of the log absence rate on the exposure indicator with fixed effects for school year, day of week and ISO week of the year, and indicators for precipitation >= 10 mm, and snowfall > 0 on the same or the previous day, for a school day next to a weekday without school, and for the last five school days of the school year. Standard errors Newey-West with 5 lags. Estimate: exp(coefficient) with its 95% interval. Secondary, not deciding: exposure on any of lags 0 to 2; a linear term per 5 C of TMAX within the arm; the hot arm without the last two weeks of June; the same model on the school-level medians is not planned.",
    "prediction": {
      "direction": "+",
      "magnitude": "Composed through asthma alone: absence ratio 1.0073 (95% interval 1.0008 to 1.0173). With an expected standard error near 0.016 on the log scale the test cannot separate this size from no effect (D = 0.23, below 4). The registrant expects the direct association to be larger than the chain, between 1.00 and 1.08, because temperature can affect attendance by routes other than asthma.",
      "refute_if": "the absence ratio is below 1 and its 95% interval excludes 1.",
      "support_if": "the absence ratio for exposed days is above 1 and its 95% interval (Newey-West) excludes 1. The direction composed from the triad is then confirmed. Whether the interval contains the composed interval is reported as a second, registered quantity (the share of the association that the asthma path can account for = composed log ratio / city log ratio)."
    },
    "prior": 0.55,
    "registered_at": "2026-11-12T22:51:37-0500",
    "registrant": "claude (graph triads study)",
    "sha256": "e209073100a94c7f01555b38f651a628241c34d9cec205401a37b1f329a42183",
    "statement": "On cold school days New York City public-school absence is higher than on other school days of the same week of the year, as the open triad temperature - asthma - school attendance in the System Public Graph implies; the graph holds no finding that links temperature to school attendance directly."
  },
  "registration_commit": {
    "commit": "3c393f8db18e9c8ac2c613a24815ae4e360d65e9",
    "committed_at": "2026-11-12T22:51:43-05:00"
  },
  "registration_file_sha256": "7cc9c150788bb4281f459f3e384599b764658df818af5127dd5f0b9289b1a8dc",
  "registration_path": "claims/registered/graph-triad-cold-asthma-absence.json",
  "registration_sha256": "e209073100a94c7f01555b38f651a628241c34d9cec205401a37b1f329a42183",
  "registration_text": "{\n \"id\": \"graph-triad-cold-asthma-absence\",\n \"kind\": \"bridge\",\n \"statement\": \"On cold school days New York City public-school absence is higher than on other school days of the same week of the year, as the open triad temperature - asthma - school attendance in the System Public Graph implies; the graph holds no finding that links temperature to school attendance directly.\",\n \"graph_evidence\": [\n  {\n   \"relationship_id\": [\n    \"4FaXcuNJRt|EAshH_Ko3h\",\n    \"EAshH_Ko3h|4FaXcuNJRt\",\n    \"dINFs04idR|EAshH_Ko3h\"\n   ],\n   \"concepts\": \"temperature family (hot, temperature, air temperature) - asthma\",\n   \"n_findings\": 40,\n   \"n_studies\": 24,\n   \"direction\": \"+ for heat in the hot season and + for cold in the cold season; the 32 positive and 8 negative rows mix both, and include heaters and exhaled temperature\",\n   \"summary\": \"cold (5th percentile of temperature) and childhood asthma hospitalisation, RR 1.64 (1.06-2.54) on days with lower PM2.5, Hefei 2013-2016; also low temperature RR 1.20 (1.15-1.26), Lanzhou (PMID 39251927), and 1.10 (1.05-1.15) in adults, Hong Kong (PMID 36240934)\",\n   \"pubmed_ids\": [\n    \"35817164\",\n    \"34555607\",\n    \"39251927\",\n    \"36240934\"\n   ]\n  },\n  {\n   \"relationship_id\": [\n    \"EAshH_Ko3h|_l4tNqo_PI\"\n   ],\n   \"concepts\": \"asthma - school attendance\",\n   \"n_findings\": 1,\n   \"n_studies\": 31,\n   \"direction\": \"+ (more days absent)\",\n   \"summary\": \"children with asthma had 2.21 (1.41-3.01) more days absent per year than matched children without asthma, Rochester, Minnesota (abstract read; the relationship record lists 31 studies but the API returns one finding)\",\n   \"pubmed_ids\": [\n    \"11487757\"\n   ]\n  },\n  {\n   \"relationship_id\": null,\n   \"concepts\": \"temperature family - school attendance\",\n   \"n_findings\": 0,\n   \"n_studies\": 0,\n   \"direction\": null,\n   \"summary\": \"no direct finding in the graph for hot, temperature, air temperature, surface temperature, heat wave or urban heat island with school attendance (two findings from two studies with absenteeism)\",\n   \"pubmed_ids\": []\n  }\n ],\n \"literature\": [\n  {\n   \"citation\": \"Keivabu RC. Temperature and school absences: evidence from England. Population and Environment 2024\",\n   \"doi\": \"10.1007/s11111-024-00448-5\",\n   \"finding\": \"hot days increase absences in English schools; cold days show no substantive effect. Not in the graph. Read as a search summary only, not the paper.\"\n  }\n ],\n \"composition\": {\n  \"method\": \"kit.bridge.compose, log RR(absence) = share x log RR(asthma exacerbation), 20000 draws, seed 1\",\n  \"link\": {\n   \"estimate\": 1.64,\n   \"lo\": 1.06,\n   \"hi\": 2.54,\n   \"pubmed_id\": \"35817164\"\n  },\n  \"exponent\": {\n   \"mean\": 0.0156,\n   \"sd\": 0.0045,\n   \"meaning\": \"share of pupil absences attributable to asthma = prevalence U(0.08, 0.15) x excess days 2.21 (1.41-3.01) / mean days absent U(13, 20); prevalence and mean days absent are the registrant's assumptions, not graph findings\"\n  },\n  \"composed_ratio_lo_median_hi\": [\n   1.0007778837133046,\n   1.0072685309733118,\n   1.0172716526590189\n  ],\n  \"discrimination\": {\n   \"endpoint_se\": 0.016,\n   \"combined_se\": 0.016544124086493393,\n   \"z_null_if_chain_true\": 0.4792985991861879,\n   \"D_expected\": 0.22972714718184198,\n   \"discriminates\": false,\n   \"p_null_passes\": 0.9330052811874541,\n   \"advice\": \"the test cannot separate the chain from no effect; find a larger contrast or a more precise endpoint\"\n  }\n },\n \"prediction\": {\n  \"direction\": \"+\",\n  \"magnitude\": \"Composed through asthma alone: absence ratio 1.0073 (95% interval 1.0008 to 1.0173). With an expected standard error near 0.016 on the log scale the test cannot separate this size from no effect (D = 0.23, below 4). The registrant expects the direct association to be larger than the chain, between 1.00 and 1.08, because temperature can affect attendance by routes other than asthma.\",\n  \"support_if\": \"the absence ratio for exposed days is above 1 and its 95% interval (Newey-West) excludes 1. The direction composed from the triad is then confirmed. Whether the interval contains the composed interval is reported as a second, registered quantity (the share of the association that the asthma path can account for = composed log ratio / city log ratio).\",\n  \"refute_if\": \"the absence ratio is below 1 and its 95% interval excludes 1.\"\n },\n \"plan\": \"Unit: school day, citywide, school years 2006-07 to 2018-19. Outcome: log(sum of absent / sum of enrolled) over all schools by date, from NYC Open Data daily attendance by school (xwxx-rnki, wpqj-3buw, pffu-gbfi, 3y5p-x48f, x3bb-kg5j), aggregated in SoQL. Exclusions fixed now: weekends; days whose citywide enrolment is below 80% of that school year's median; days with an absence rate above 30%. Arm: school days in December, January and February. Exposure: Central Park TMAX <= 0.0 C on the same day (NOAA GHCN-Daily USW00094728). Model: OLS of the log absence rate on the exposure indicator with fixed effects for school year, day of week and ISO week of the year, and indicators for precipitation >= 10 mm, and snowfall > 0 on the same or the previous day, for a school day next to a weekday without school, and for the last five school days of the school year. Standard errors Newey-West with 5 lags. Estimate: exp(coefficient) with its 95% interval. Secondary, not deciding: exposure on any of lags 0 to 2; a linear term per 5 C of TMAX within the arm; the hot arm without the last two weeks of June; the same model on the school-level medians is not planned.\",\n \"alternatives\": [\n  \"Temperature affects attendance directly (discomfort, travel, classrooms without air conditioning, families' choices), not through asthma; a ratio far above the composed interval indicates this.\",\n  \"Calendar: late June is hot and attendance falls at the end of the year; winter cold coincides with influenza season and snow. Week-of-year and school-year effects and the snow indicator address this in part; influenza is not controlled.\",\n  \"Citywide aggregation hides schools that close or report late on extreme days; the exclusions address this in part.\",\n  \"The asthma links come from hospital admissions in Hong Kong, Hefei, Lanzhou and Florida and from 92 children in Minnesota; none is a New York school population.\"\n ],\n \"disclosure\": \"No attendance data had been queried by this project before registration (no file for these datasets in data/cache/socrata; only the catalog's column names were read). The Central Park temperature series had been used by earlier claims, and the counts of exposed days (116 of 843 hot-season weekdays, 145 of 838 cold-season weekdays) were computed from it before registration. The registrant knows in general that New York attendance falls in late June and on snow days. A web search summary of Keivabu 2024 was read before registration.\",\n \"prior\": 0.55,\n \"registrant\": \"claude (graph triads study)\",\n \"chain\": [\n  \"temperature -> asthma exacerbation (graph)\",\n  \"asthma -> days absent (graph)\"\n ],\n \"registered_at\": \"2026-11-12T22:51:37-0500\",\n \"sha256\": \"e209073100a94c7f01555b38f651a628241c34d9cec205401a37b1f329a42183\"\n}",
  "statement": "On cold school days New York City public-school absence is higher than on other school days of the same week of the year, as the open triad temperature - asthma - school attendance in the System Public Graph implies; the graph holds no finding that links temperature to school attendance directly."
}

History in this collection

  1. addedv1.0.0Nov 14, 2026this version