Claim at v1.2.0

mob-crz-air-nyccas

e86bc6350488967f5f2cfbf91fee4a5e01e14a8962a83e0fcd753c52791db36a

Data

{
  "has_outcome": true,
  "kind": "confirmation",
  "lineage": {
    "audit": "docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json",
    "class": "none",
    "class_meaning": "the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration",
    "classes": [],
    "early_sources": []
  },
  "outcome": "mob-crz-air-nyccas",
  "prior": 0.3,
  "registered_at": "2026-11-12T15:24:55-0500",
  "registrant": "mobility agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon",
  "registration": {
    "alternatives": [
      "Regional background change (wildfire smoke in 2023, transported sulfate) — absorbed by date effects only if it is spatially uniform",
      "Local construction or site-specific changes near a single in-zone monitor",
      "Long-run decline in vehicle emissions that is faster in Manhattan (fleet turnover, bus electrification)",
      "Traffic diverted to highways near comparison monitors (e.g. Cross Bronx) raises the comparison and inflates the DiD",
      "NYCCAS annual surfaces are model-based (land-use regression on street-level monitors); if the model uses traffic inputs that were updated for 2025, the result is partly circular. Its method notes must be read before the result is used.",
      "The 2023 Canadian wildfire smoke episode raised 2023 PM2.5 citywide (absorbed by year effects if uniform)."
    ],
    "graph_evidence": [
      {
        "note": "No road-pricing findings in the graph (see mob-crz-traffic). The traffic-to-pollutant link is thin: traffic-related pollution -> NO2 has 1 finding; traffic -> particulates and traffic -> NO2 return no relationship. The downstream health link is dense:"
      },
      {
        "concepts": [
          "nitrogen dioxide",
          "asthma"
        ],
        "direction": "+",
        "n_findings": 97,
        "n_studies": 62,
        "pubmed_ids": [
          9371204,
          9387953,
          9849541,
          10193370,
          11034970,
          11153587,
          11359423,
          11480499,
          12507172,
          12550084,
          15075170,
          16222162,
          16506437,
          16984840,
          17100666,
          17357797,
          17582483,
          17903240,
          18467319,
          18941590,
          19251785,
          19965811,
          20371422,
          21034384,
          21432566
        ],
        "relationship_id": "DC_F0GO0WQ|EAshH_Ko3h",
        "summary": "91 ratio findings; 78 above 1, 12 below; 59 with CI above 1, 7 with CI below 1; median ratio 1.16 (mixed increments and designs)"
      },
      {
        "concepts": [
          "particulates",
          "asthma"
        ],
        "direction": "+",
        "n_findings": 133,
        "n_studies": 77,
        "pubmed_ids": [
          1954938,
          7786050,
          8256893,
          11480499,
          12055048,
          12361942,
          12550084,
          12676630,
          14594699,
          18467319,
          19359271,
          19965811,
          20056967,
          21216722,
          21432566,
          21659039,
          22484788,
          22490087,
          24657516,
          24802555,
          24858282,
          25593604,
          25688676,
          26404109,
          26618316
        ],
        "relationship_id": "gX6h_gZWHH|EAshH_Ko3h",
        "summary": "157 ratio findings; 144 above 1, 9 below; 88 with CI above 1, 4 with CI below 1; median ratio 1.15 (mixed increments and designs)"
      },
      {
        "concepts": [
          "traffic-related pollution",
          "asthma"
        ],
        "direction": "+",
        "n_findings": 51,
        "n_studies": 29,
        "pubmed_ids": [
          7542442,
          10810096,
          11575896,
          11908931,
          14684722,
          16007113,
          18941591,
          19151227,
          19478970,
          19620729,
          20371422,
          20561230,
          21631953,
          21890573,
          23222555,
          24659182,
          24680015,
          26106807,
          26365004,
          26862123,
          27325078,
          28605396,
          31303647,
          31665023,
          33187300
        ],
        "relationship_id": "oG8Da1gCE9|EAshH_Ko3h",
        "summary": "49 ratio findings; 46 above 1, 3 below; 35 with CI above 1, 0 with CI below 1; median ratio 1.51 (mixed increments and designs)"
      }
    ],
    "id": "mob-crz-air-nyccas",
    "kind": "confirmation",
    "literature": [
      {
        "citation": "Johansson C, Burman L, Forsberg B (2009). The effects of congestions tax on air quality and health. Atmos Environ 43:4843-4854.",
        "doi": "10.1016/j.atmosenv.2008.09.015",
        "finding": "Modelled NOx emissions in inner Stockholm fell 8.5%, PM10 emissions about 13%; concentration changes were smaller."
      },
      {
        "citation": "Kelly F et al. (2011). The impact of the congestion charging scheme on air quality in London. HEI Research Report 155.",
        "doi": null,
        "finding": "Little detectable change in measured NOx, NO2 or PM10 attributable to the London charge."
      },
      {
        "citation": "Simeonova E, Currie J, Nilsson P, Walker R (2021). Congestion pricing, air pollution, and children's health. J Human Resources 56(4):971-996.",
        "doi": "10.3368/jhr.56.4.0218-9363R2",
        "finding": "Stockholm charge lowered ambient pollution 5-15% and acute asthma visits of young children."
      },
      {
        "citation": "Fraser T, Park YG, Lu D, Tayarani M, Deng H, Gao HO (2025). A first look into congestion pricing in the United States: PM2.5 impacts after six months of New York City cordon pricing. npj Clean Air 1:39.",
        "doi": "10.1038/s44407-025-00037-2",
        "finding": "Daily maximum PM2.5 in the CRZ fell 3.05 ug/m3 (22%) against a counterfactual, Jan-Jun 2025, 42 monitors (press coverage; paper not read in full)."
      },
      {
        "citation": "NYC DOHMH (14 August 2026). Congestion pricing air quality report.",
        "doi": null,
        "finding": "PM2.5, NO2, NO and black carbon in the CBD were not significantly different from the no-toll counterfactual in 2025 (secondary report)."
      }
    ],
    "plan": "Data: NYC DOHMH Environment and Health Data Portal, github.com/nychealth/EHDP-data at commit 547482b9df589006543e13e8cdf6546e00ed9998, indicator 2025 (NO2, measure 1431 annual mean, ppb) and indicator 2023 (PM2.5, measure 1425 annual mean, ug/m3), GeoType UHF42, years 2021-2025. In-zone: UHF 306 Chelsea-Clinton, 307 Gramercy Park-Murray Hill, 308 Greenwich Village-SoHo, 309 Union Square-Lower East Side, 310 Lower Manhattan. Adjacent (reported, excluded from the main comparison): 301-305. Comparison: UHFs in the Bronx, Brooklyn, Queens and Staten Island. Model: OLS of log value on UHF and year fixed effects and inzone x post (post = 2025). Inference: placebo-in-space, the same estimator for every set of 5 comparison UHFs drawn at random (5,000 draws), giving a one-sided p and the 2.5-97.5% band of placebo estimates around the estimate; placebo-in-time with post = 2024 on 2021-2024. Figure: annual NO2 by group, 2014-2025, with the in-zone minus comparison difference.",
    "prediction": {
      "direction": "-",
      "magnitude": "DiD of log annual NO2, UHF 306-310 vs the 32 UHFs outside Manhattan, 2025 vs 2021-2024: -3% to -10%. PM2.5 (secondary): 0% to -6%.",
      "refute_if": "NO2 DiD at or above 0, or within the central 80% of the placebo-in-space distribution.",
      "support_if": "NO2 DiD below 0, and below the 5th percentile of the placebo-in-space distribution (one-sided p < 0.05)."
    },
    "prior": 0.3,
    "registered_at": "2026-11-12T15:24:55-0500",
    "registrant": "mobility agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon",
    "sha256": "12a668a997839133b62c44c15db11750f0546e875f070963223d5b55759f39f5",
    "statement": "NYCCAS annual average NO2 in the five UHF42 neighbourhoods south of 60th Street fell from 2024 to 2025, after congestion pricing began, more than in neighbourhoods outside Manhattan.",
    "supersedes": "mob-crz-air",
    "why_superseded": "The registered primary test of mob-crz-air (daily NO2 at EPA AQS monitors inside the zone) could not run: the AQS daily files for 2022-2025 contain no NO2 monitor in New York County. The NYC Community Air Survey (NYCCAS) annual averages by UHF42 include 2025."
  },
  "registration_commit": {
    "commit": "2199e6a9a2f1ffb45a2c8435531972fb5febed69",
    "committed_at": "2026-11-12T15:24:55-05:00"
  },
  "registration_file_sha256": "4badba8c1513e9f7de56dad945eec708765e0f5ec3071ccc28d779bc0fb8459a",
  "registration_path": "claims/registered/mob-crz-air-nyccas.json",
  "registration_sha256": "12a668a997839133b62c44c15db11750f0546e875f070963223d5b55759f39f5",
  "registration_text": "{\n \"id\": \"mob-crz-air-nyccas\",\n \"supersedes\": \"mob-crz-air\",\n \"kind\": \"confirmation\",\n \"statement\": \"NYCCAS annual average NO2 in the five UHF42 neighbourhoods south of 60th Street fell from 2024 to 2025, after congestion pricing began, more than in neighbourhoods outside Manhattan.\",\n \"why_superseded\": \"The registered primary test of mob-crz-air (daily NO2 at EPA AQS monitors inside the zone) could not run: the AQS daily files for 2022-2025 contain no NO2 monitor in New York County. The NYC Community Air Survey (NYCCAS) annual averages by UHF42 include 2025.\",\n \"graph_evidence\": [\n  {\n   \"note\": \"No road-pricing findings in the graph (see mob-crz-traffic). The traffic-to-pollutant link is thin: traffic-related pollution -> NO2 has 1 finding; traffic -> particulates and traffic -> NO2 return no relationship. The downstream health link is dense:\"\n  },\n  {\n   \"relationship_id\": \"DC_F0GO0WQ|EAshH_Ko3h\",\n   \"concepts\": [\n    \"nitrogen dioxide\",\n    \"asthma\"\n   ],\n   \"n_findings\": 97,\n   \"n_studies\": 62,\n   \"direction\": \"+\",\n   \"summary\": \"91 ratio findings; 78 above 1, 12 below; 59 with CI above 1, 7 with CI below 1; median ratio 1.16 (mixed increments and designs)\",\n   \"pubmed_ids\": [\n    9371204,\n    9387953,\n    9849541,\n    10193370,\n    11034970,\n    11153587,\n    11359423,\n    11480499,\n    12507172,\n    12550084,\n    15075170,\n    16222162,\n    16506437,\n    16984840,\n    17100666,\n    17357797,\n    17582483,\n    17903240,\n    18467319,\n    18941590,\n    19251785,\n    19965811,\n    20371422,\n    21034384,\n    21432566\n   ]\n  },\n  {\n   \"relationship_id\": \"gX6h_gZWHH|EAshH_Ko3h\",\n   \"concepts\": [\n    \"particulates\",\n    \"asthma\"\n   ],\n   \"n_findings\": 133,\n   \"n_studies\": 77,\n   \"direction\": \"+\",\n   \"summary\": \"157 ratio findings; 144 above 1, 9 below; 88 with CI above 1, 4 with CI below 1; median ratio 1.15 (mixed increments and designs)\",\n   \"pubmed_ids\": [\n    1954938,\n    7786050,\n    8256893,\n    11480499,\n    12055048,\n    12361942,\n    12550084,\n    12676630,\n    14594699,\n    18467319,\n    19359271,\n    19965811,\n    20056967,\n    21216722,\n    21432566,\n    21659039,\n    22484788,\n    22490087,\n    24657516,\n    24802555,\n    24858282,\n    25593604,\n    25688676,\n    26404109,\n    26618316\n   ]\n  },\n  {\n   \"relationship_id\": \"oG8Da1gCE9|EAshH_Ko3h\",\n   \"concepts\": [\n    \"traffic-related pollution\",\n    \"asthma\"\n   ],\n   \"n_findings\": 51,\n   \"n_studies\": 29,\n   \"direction\": \"+\",\n   \"summary\": \"49 ratio findings; 46 above 1, 3 below; 35 with CI above 1, 0 with CI below 1; median ratio 1.51 (mixed increments and designs)\",\n   \"pubmed_ids\": [\n    7542442,\n    10810096,\n    11575896,\n    11908931,\n    14684722,\n    16007113,\n    18941591,\n    19151227,\n    19478970,\n    19620729,\n    20371422,\n    20561230,\n    21631953,\n    21890573,\n    23222555,\n    24659182,\n    24680015,\n    26106807,\n    26365004,\n    26862123,\n    27325078,\n    28605396,\n    31303647,\n    31665023,\n    33187300\n   ]\n  }\n ],\n \"literature\": [\n  {\n   \"citation\": \"Johansson C, Burman L, Forsberg B (2009). The effects of congestions tax on air quality and health. Atmos Environ 43:4843-4854.\",\n   \"doi\": \"10.1016/j.atmosenv.2008.09.015\",\n   \"finding\": \"Modelled NOx emissions in inner Stockholm fell 8.5%, PM10 emissions about 13%; concentration changes were smaller.\"\n  },\n  {\n   \"citation\": \"Kelly F et al. (2011). The impact of the congestion charging scheme on air quality in London. HEI Research Report 155.\",\n   \"doi\": null,\n   \"finding\": \"Little detectable change in measured NOx, NO2 or PM10 attributable to the London charge.\"\n  },\n  {\n   \"citation\": \"Simeonova E, Currie J, Nilsson P, Walker R (2021). Congestion pricing, air pollution, and children's health. J Human Resources 56(4):971-996.\",\n   \"doi\": \"10.3368/jhr.56.4.0218-9363R2\",\n   \"finding\": \"Stockholm charge lowered ambient pollution 5-15% and acute asthma visits of young children.\"\n  },\n  {\n   \"citation\": \"Fraser T, Park YG, Lu D, Tayarani M, Deng H, Gao HO (2025). A first look into congestion pricing in the United States: PM2.5 impacts after six months of New York City cordon pricing. npj Clean Air 1:39.\",\n   \"doi\": \"10.1038/s44407-025-00037-2\",\n   \"finding\": \"Daily maximum PM2.5 in the CRZ fell 3.05 ug/m3 (22%) against a counterfactual, Jan-Jun 2025, 42 monitors (press coverage; paper not read in full).\"\n  },\n  {\n   \"citation\": \"NYC DOHMH (14 August 2026). Congestion pricing air quality report.\",\n   \"doi\": null,\n   \"finding\": \"PM2.5, NO2, NO and black carbon in the CBD were not significantly different from the no-toll counterfactual in 2025 (secondary report).\"\n  }\n ],\n \"prediction\": {\n  \"direction\": \"-\",\n  \"magnitude\": \"DiD of log annual NO2, UHF 306-310 vs the 32 UHFs outside Manhattan, 2025 vs 2021-2024: -3% to -10%. PM2.5 (secondary): 0% to -6%.\",\n  \"support_if\": \"NO2 DiD below 0, and below the 5th percentile of the placebo-in-space distribution (one-sided p < 0.05).\",\n  \"refute_if\": \"NO2 DiD at or above 0, or within the central 80% of the placebo-in-space distribution.\"\n },\n \"plan\": \"Data: NYC DOHMH Environment and Health Data Portal, github.com/nychealth/EHDP-data at commit 547482b9df589006543e13e8cdf6546e00ed9998, indicator 2025 (NO2, measure 1431 annual mean, ppb) and indicator 2023 (PM2.5, measure 1425 annual mean, ug/m3), GeoType UHF42, years 2021-2025. In-zone: UHF 306 Chelsea-Clinton, 307 Gramercy Park-Murray Hill, 308 Greenwich Village-SoHo, 309 Union Square-Lower East Side, 310 Lower Manhattan. Adjacent (reported, excluded from the main comparison): 301-305. Comparison: UHFs in the Bronx, Brooklyn, Queens and Staten Island. Model: OLS of log value on UHF and year fixed effects and inzone x post (post = 2025). Inference: placebo-in-space, the same estimator for every set of 5 comparison UHFs drawn at random (5,000 draws), giving a one-sided p and the 2.5-97.5% band of placebo estimates around the estimate; placebo-in-time with post = 2024 on 2021-2024. Figure: annual NO2 by group, 2014-2025, with the in-zone minus comparison difference.\",\n \"alternatives\": [\n  \"Regional background change (wildfire smoke in 2023, transported sulfate) — absorbed by date effects only if it is spatially uniform\",\n  \"Local construction or site-specific changes near a single in-zone monitor\",\n  \"Long-run decline in vehicle emissions that is faster in Manhattan (fleet turnover, bus electrification)\",\n  \"Traffic diverted to highways near comparison monitors (e.g. Cross Bronx) raises the comparison and inflates the DiD\",\n  \"NYCCAS annual surfaces are model-based (land-use regression on street-level monitors); if the model uses traffic inputs that were updated for 2025, the result is partly circular. Its method notes must be read before the result is used.\",\n  \"The 2023 Canadian wildfire smoke episode raised 2023 PM2.5 citywide (absorbed by year effects if uniform).\"\n ],\n \"prior\": 0.3,\n \"registrant\": \"mobility agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon\",\n \"registered_at\": \"2026-11-12T15:24:55-0500\",\n \"sha256\": \"12a668a997839133b62c44c15db11750f0546e875f070963223d5b55759f39f5\"\n}",
  "statement": "NYCCAS annual average NO2 in the five UHF42 neighbourhoods south of 60th Street fell from 2024 to 2025, after congestion pricing began, more than in neighbourhoods outside Manhattan.",
  "supersedes": "mob-crz-air"
}

History in this collection

  1. addedv1.0.0Nov 14, 2026this version