Automated verdicts

70 records0 files121.5 KiB total2 types
via ground-truthNov 14, 2026ulv3:5ed68a446d6a…ark:12345/ulcb4q41b0g2bpzv.v1.0.0
idtitlekindverdictinputsbridgeNotechaincityresearchresolutionsettletriage
ac-protectsAir conditioning protects against heat illnessdirectinconclusive[{"collection":"nyc/environment-health","collectionId":"702c055e-4d37-4c6d-a769-0ebe4ea89307","label":"households with air conditioning (%)","period":"2017","query":null,"recordIds":["781:UHF42:101:46…—["air conditioning","heat illness"]{"ci":[-0.58,-0.04],"n":42,"p":0.02921,"partialRhoPoverty":-0.015,"q":0.09614,"rho":-0.337,"unit":"UHF42 neighborhood","x":"households with air conditioning (%)","y":"heat-stress hospitalizations per …{"agreement":1,"direction":"-","dois":["10.1007/s00484-016-1189-9","10.1016/s0749-3797(02)00421-x"],"evidenceFit":0.3,"excludedAfterReview":0,"findings":2,"nycStudies":0,"studies":2}—Air-conditioner use during heat waves (not ownership), by neighborhood, plus heat deaths at home.["poverty confounding"]
bridge-no-heat-cold-edApartments without winter heat send people to the ER for coldbridgeinconclusive[{"collection":"nyc/heat-complaints","collectionId":"535e4a8d-4d10-4607-84a8-2da81820daaf","label":"311 no-heat complaints per 1,000 residents per winter","period":"winters 2024-25, 2025-26","query":"…—["cold homes (no heat)","cold, respiratory and general health harm"]{"ci":[0.04,0.53],"n":57,"p":0.01891,"partialRhoPoverty":0.021,"q":0.09614,"rho":0.31,"unit":"community district","x":"311 no-heat complaints per 1,000 residents per winter","y":"cold-related ED visit…{"agreement":0.75,"direction":"+","dois":["10.1016/j.annepidem.2017.11.008","10.1016/j.ssmph.2020.100665","10.1186/s12199-021-01024-1","10.3390/ijerph18105133","10.3390/ijerph18115961"],"evidenceFit":…—Indoor winter temperatures in buildings with repeated no-heat complaints.["poverty confounding","population mismatch"]
bridge-trees-heat-edStreet trees mean fewer heat ER visits, through cooler streetsbridgebridged[{"collection":"nyc/street-trees","collectionId":"34230af0-0d7a-4376-abd1-65477d836388","label":"living street trees per km²","period":"2015 census","query":"count of Tree records with status='Alive' …The end-to-end link is tested directly; living street trees per km² → daytime summer surface temperature (°F) does not hold (ρ +0.18), daytime summer surface temperature (°F) → heat-stress ED visits p…["trees and greenery","local temperature","heat illness, hospital and ER visits"]{"ci":[-0.51,-0.02],"n":57,"p":0.03635,"partialRhoPoverty":-0.277,"q":0.09614,"rho":-0.278,"unit":"community district","x":"living street trees per km²","y":"heat-stress ED visits per 100,000 (5-year,…{"agreement":null,"direction":"-","dois":["10.1002/ehf2.12506","10.1007/s00240-024-01560-9","10.1007/s00484-022-02278-2","10.1007/s11356-020-09814-w","10.1007/s11356-022-23445-3","10.1007/s12199-011-0…—A district study of trees, indoor heat and ER visits that adjusts for income and housing age.["population mismatch","mechanism unconfirmed"]
canopy-coolsTree canopy cools neighborhoodsdirectcontested[{"collection":"nyc/environment-health","collectionId":"702c055e-4d37-4c6d-a769-0ebe4ea89307","label":"tree canopy cover (%)","period":"2014","query":null,"recordIds":["708:UHF42:101:41","708:UHF42:10…—["trees and greenery","local temperature"]{"ci":[-0.66,-0.06],"n":42,"p":0.00609,"partialRhoPoverty":-0.397,"q":0.06699,"rho":-0.416,"unit":"UHF42 neighborhood","x":"tree canopy cover (%)","y":"daytime summer surface temperature (°F)"}{"agreement":0.57,"direction":"mixed","dois":["10.1007/s11356-022-23445-3","10.1098/rsta.2015.0219","10.1109/agro-geoinformatics.2012.6311657","10.1117/12.2324740","10.1117/12.2573921","10.21660/2020.…The studies disagree. New York's data take a side: where tree canopy cover (%) is higher, daytime summer surface temperature (°F) is lower (ρ -0.42, n 42).Street-level air temperature sensors next to canopy measurements.["research mixed","population mismatch"]
greenery-cools-cdGreener districts are coolerdirectinconclusive[{"collection":"nyc/environment-health","collectionId":"702c055e-4d37-4c6d-a769-0ebe4ea89307","label":"grass and tree cover (%)","period":"2017","query":null,"recordIds":["690:CD:101:46","690:CD:102:4…—["trees and greenery","local temperature"]{"ci":[-0.45,0.04],"n":59,"p":0.09529,"partialRhoPoverty":-0.188,"q":0.14974,"rho":-0.219,"unit":"community district","x":"grass and tree cover (%)","y":"daytime summer surface temperature (°F)"}{"agreement":0.57,"direction":"mixed","dois":["10.1007/s11356-022-23445-3","10.1098/rsta.2015.0219","10.1109/agro-geoinformatics.2012.6311657","10.1117/12.2324740","10.1117/12.2573921","10.21660/2020.…—Block-level greenery and temperature: 59 districts average away the contrast.["scale","research mixed","population mismatch"]
hot-districts-asthmaHotter districts have more asthma emergenciesdirectconfirmed[{"collection":"nyc/environment-health","collectionId":"702c055e-4d37-4c6d-a769-0ebe4ea89307","label":"daytime summer surface temperature (°F)","period":"2018","query":null,"recordIds":["688:CD:101:47…—["heat exposure","asthma"]{"ci":[0.01,0.47],"n":59,"p":0.0437,"partialRhoPoverty":0.167,"q":0.09614,"rho":0.264,"unit":"community district","x":"daytime summer surface temperature (°F)","y":"adult asthma ED visits per 10,000 (…{"agreement":0.95,"direction":"+","dois":["10.1016/j.envint.2018.02.023","10.1016/j.envint.2022.107456","10.1016/j.envres.2018.12.002","10.1016/j.envres.2021.110738","10.1016/j.envres.2023.115679","10…——[]
hot-districts-heat-edHotter districts send more people to the ER for heatdirectcontested[{"collection":"nyc/environment-health","collectionId":"702c055e-4d37-4c6d-a769-0ebe4ea89307","label":"daytime summer surface temperature (°F)","period":"2018","query":null,"recordIds":["688:CD:101:47…—["heat exposure","heat illness, hospital and ER visits"]{"ci":[-0.44,0.07],"n":57,"p":0.15628,"partialRhoPoverty":-0.225,"q":0.21488,"rho":-0.19,"unit":"community district","x":"daytime summer surface temperature (°F)","y":"heat-stress ED visits per 100,00…{"agreement":0.94,"direction":"+","dois":["10.1001/jama.2014.15715","10.1002/ehf2.12506","10.1007/s00240-015-0779-z","10.1007/s00240-024-01560-9","10.1007/s00484-009-0241-4","10.1007/s00484-016-1261-5…—Indoor temperatures in homes, by district. Satellite surface temperature measures roofs and pavement, not the apartments where people get sick.["weak proxy","population mismatch"]
hot-summers-hospitalizationsHotter summers send more New Yorkers to hospital for heatdirectconfirmed[{"collection":"noaa/nyc-daily-weather","collectionId":"2fe232ca-088a-45fc-8dd8-e7d65813a01e","label":"days at or above 90°F (Central Park)","period":"yearly","query":"Day records for station USW00094…—["heat exposure","heat illness, hospital and ER visits"]{"ci":[-0.09,0.76],"n":22,"p":0.05446,"partialRhoPoverty":null,"q":0.09984,"rho":0.416,"unit":"year","x":"days at or above 90°F (Central Park)","y":"heat-stress hospitalizations, citywide (sum of 5 bo…{"agreement":0.94,"direction":"+","dois":["10.1001/jama.2014.15715","10.1002/ehf2.12506","10.1007/s00240-015-0779-z","10.1007/s00240-024-01560-9","10.1007/s00484-009-0241-4","10.1007/s00484-016-1261-5…——[]
older-alone-heat-edDistricts with more older adults living alone have more heat illnessdirectinconclusive[{"collection":"nyc/environment-health","collectionId":"702c055e-4d37-4c6d-a769-0ebe4ea89307","label":"adults 65+ living alone (%)","period":"2015-19","query":null,"recordIds":["693:CD:101:287","693:C…—["older adults living alone","heat illness"]{"ci":[-0.14,0.37],"n":57,"p":0.39858,"partialRhoPoverty":0.055,"q":0.39858,"rho":0.114,"unit":"community district","x":"adults 65+ living alone (%)","y":"heat-stress ED visits per 100,000 (5-year, ag…{"agreement":1,"direction":"+","dois":["10.1007/s00484-016-1189-9","10.1016/s0749-3797(02)00421-x","10.1038/srep39581","10.1136/oem.2010.062141","10.1186/1472-6947-9-14"],"evidenceFit":0.28,"excludedA…—Heat ER visits for ages 65+ by district, instead of all-age rates.["population mismatch","poverty confounding"]
poverty-heat-edPoorer districts suffer more heat illnessdirectinconclusive[{"collection":"nyc/environment-health","collectionId":"702c055e-4d37-4c6d-a769-0ebe4ea89307","label":"residents below poverty (%)","period":"2015-19","query":null,"recordIds":["221:CD:101:287","221:C…—["poverty","heat illness"]{"ci":[-0.11,0.41],"n":57,"p":0.20705,"partialRhoPoverty":null,"q":0.22776,"rho":0.17,"unit":"community district","x":"residents below poverty (%)","y":"heat-stress ED visits per 100,000 (5-year, age-…{"agreement":1,"direction":"+","dois":["10.1111/1753-6405.12253","10.17269/cjph.107.5599"],"evidenceFit":0.125,"excludedAfterReview":0,"findings":8,"nycStudies":0,"studies":2}—Heat deaths by district: poorer residents may die at home without reaching an ER.["weak proxy","population mismatch"]
trees-coolCounting street trees tells you which districts are coolerdirectinconclusive[{"collection":"nyc/street-trees","collectionId":"34230af0-0d7a-4376-abd1-65477d836388","label":"living street trees per km²","period":"2015 census","query":"count of Tree records with status='Alive' …—["trees and greenery","local temperature"]{"ci":[-0.09,0.41],"n":59,"p":0.18231,"partialRhoPoverty":0.174,"q":0.22282,"rho":0.176,"unit":"community district","x":"living street trees per km²","y":"daytime summer surface temperature (°F)"}{"agreement":0.57,"direction":"mixed","dois":["10.1007/s11356-022-23445-3","10.1098/rsta.2015.0219","10.1109/agro-geoinformatics.2012.6311657","10.1117/12.2324740","10.1117/12.2573921","10.21660/2020.…—Canopy area instead of tree counts: a young street tree shades almost nothing. Compare with the canopy claim.["weak proxy","research mixed","population mismatch"]