Claim at v1.0.0
repro-mmr-cbd-speed
6dcbea45d34c6f18856a605a78991469755399e7372add09476cbbe96317f6f0
Data
{
"has_outcome": true,
"kind": "reproduction",
"lineage": {
"audit": "docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json",
"class": "b",
"class_meaning": "a design, power or calibration read, pre-period data, or metadata",
"classes": [
"b"
],
"early_sources": [
{
"class": "b",
"dataset": "6p29-6xqn",
"evidence": "MTA monthly CBD speed series, fetched for mob-crz-traffic. Referee: \"a related speed measure\" about 1.7 mph above the MMR figure, so it \"could not have been used to tune R1\". Trip records fetched after registration.",
"fetched": "2026-11-12T15:17:57-05:00",
"name": "MTA Central Business District Taxi and For-Hire Vehicle Speeds: Beginning October 2019"
},
{
"class": "b",
"dataset": "8meu-9t5y",
"evidence": "TLC taxi zone lookup (zone names and boroughs): metadata. Referee: \"The zone tables are not outcome data.\"",
"fetched": "2026-11-12T19:55:09-05:00",
"name": "NYC Taxi Zones"
},
{
"class": "b",
"dataset": "yfdc-w5jh",
"evidence": "MTA list of CBD taxi zones: metadata. Referee: \"The zone tables are not outcome data.\"",
"fetched": "2026-11-12T15:16:25-05:00",
"name": "MTA Central Business District Taxi Zones"
}
]
},
"outcome": "repro-mmr-cbd-speed",
"prereg_branch": {
"name": "prereg/repro-mmr-cbd-speed",
"sha": "016ac7a0559035823965f7243ebe8114e4eeab1e"
},
"prior": 0.35,
"registered_at": "2026-11-12T19:56:25-0500",
"registrant": "reproduction agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon",
"registration": {
"alternatives": [
"DOT uses GPS traces or a probe-vehicle feed (not trip records), so trip-record speeds differ in level",
"DOT uses a different zone set or a different time rule (trip wholly within 8AM-6PM)",
"DOT averages differently (mean of trip speeds, mean of monthly values, or a segment-weighted mean)",
"TLC revisions to the trip files since DOT computed the figure"
],
"graph_evidence": [],
"id": "repro-mmr-cbd-speed",
"kind": "reproduction",
"literature": [
{
"citation": "NYC DOT (2019). New York City Mobility Report.",
"data_access": "open",
"doi": null,
"finding": "DOT has computed CBD travel speeds from taxi data in earlier reports; the trip-record method is not documented in the MMR."
},
{
"citation": "MTA. CBD Taxi and For-Hire Vehicle Speeds: Beginning October 2019 (data.ny.gov 6p29-6xqn).",
"data_access": "open",
"doi": null,
"finding": "Monthly zonal speed for the CBD from TLC records; used here as a cross-check, not as the target."
}
],
"plan": "Data: TLC yellow taxi monthly parquet files for July 2023 to June 2026 (36 files from d37ci6vzurychx.cloudfront.net/trip-data/, cited by URL, Last-Modified and ETag), read with duckdb and kept in ~/opt/nyc-concordance/ outside Dropbox. Socrata copies rwwi-khbc (2024) and irx2-vgm4 (2025) are queried through concord/socrata.py for a monthly check of trip count and summed trip_distance under the R1 zone, hour, weekday and holiday conditions, so that the parquet files are shown to match the open-data copies. Compute FY24, FY25 and FY26 under R1 to R9. Cross-check: the MTA monthly CBD zonal speed (6p29-6xqn, data.ny.gov) averaged over the same fiscal years, descriptive only. Reconciliation with mob-crz-traffic (zone speeds +5.7% against the rest of the city) and the MTA's +4%: monthly R1 series July 2023 to June 2026 for the CBD and for trips within Manhattan north of 60th Street, calendar 2024 against 2025, and the split of FY25 into its untolled (Jul-Dec 2024) and tolled (Jan-Jun 2025) halves. These are descriptive and do not decide the verdict. Figure: monthly CBD speed under R1 and R2 with the MMR fiscal-year values drawn as steps, in figures/reproduction/.",
"prediction": {
"direction": "0",
"magnitude": "Tolerance: the reproduced value is within 0.2 mph of the stated value for FY25 (6.9) and for FY26 (6.5). The stated values are rounded to 0.1 mph, so 0.2 mph allows for rounding plus a small difference of method.",
"refute_if": "No registered reading R1 to R9 gives both FY25 and FY26 within 0.2 mph (verdict contested). If some readings other than R1 reproduce both and R1 does not, or R1 reproduces one year only, the verdict is unsettled.",
"secondary": "(a) The FY25 to FY26 change, stated as -0.4 mph (-5.8%), is reproduced within 0.2 mph under R1. (b) FY24 (6.9) within 0.2 mph under R1. These are reported, and do not decide the verdict.",
"support_if": "Under the primary reading R1, |FY25 - 6.9| <= 0.2 and |FY26 - 6.5| <= 0.2 (verdict confirmed)."
},
"prior": 0.35,
"readings": {
"R1": "Trips with pickup AND drop-off in the 38 MTA CBD taxi zones (yfdc-w5jh: 4, 12, 13, 45, 48, 50, 68, 79, 87, 88, 90, 100, 107, 113, 114, 125, 137, 144, 148, 158, 161, 162, 163, 164, 170, 186, 209, 211, 224, 229, 230, 231, 232, 233, 234, 246, 249, 261); pickup time 08:00:00 to 17:59:59 local, Monday to Friday; the 11 US federal holidays (observed dates) excluded; trip filter F1; speed = total trip_distance / total trip time (ratio of sums) over all qualifying trips in the fiscal year; no passenger_count filter (every trip record is a paid passenger trip).",
"R2": "As R1, but the arithmetic mean of per-trip speeds.",
"R3": "As R1, but the median of per-trip speeds.",
"R4": "As R1, but pickup in the CBD with drop-off anywhere.",
"R5": "As R1, but pickup or drop-off in the CBD.",
"R6": "As R1, but filter F0 (minimal) instead of F1.",
"R7": "As R1, but filter F2 (strict) instead of F1.",
"R8": "As R1, but only passenger_count >= 1 (records with 0 or null passengers dropped), and only the six major holidays excluded.",
"R9": "As R1, but the fiscal-year value is the unweighted mean of the twelve monthly ratio-of-sums values.",
"filters": {
"F0": "trip_distance > 0, duration > 0, speed < 100 mph",
"F1": "0 < trip_distance <= 50 miles, 60 s <= duration <= 3 h, 0.5 <= speed <= 50 mph",
"F2": "0.2 <= trip_distance <= 20 miles, 120 s <= duration <= 90 min, 1 <= speed <= 35 mph"
},
"fiscal_year_assignment": "by pickup date; trips whose pickup timestamp falls outside the file's month are dropped",
"holidays_federal_observed": [
"2023-07-04",
"2023-09-04",
"2023-10-09",
"2023-11-10",
"2023-11-23",
"2023-12-25",
"2024-01-01",
"2024-01-15",
"2024-02-19",
"2024-05-27",
"2024-06-19",
"2024-07-04",
"2024-09-02",
"2024-10-14",
"2024-11-11",
"2024-11-28",
"2024-12-25",
"2025-01-01",
"2025-01-20",
"2025-02-17",
"2025-05-26",
"2025-06-19",
"2025-07-04",
"2025-09-01",
"2025-10-13",
"2025-11-11",
"2025-11-27",
"2025-12-25",
"2026-01-01",
"2026-01-19",
"2026-02-16",
"2026-05-25",
"2026-06-19"
],
"holidays_major6": [
"2023-07-04",
"2023-09-04",
"2023-11-23",
"2023-12-25",
"2024-01-01",
"2024-05-27",
"2024-07-04",
"2024-09-02",
"2024-11-28",
"2024-12-25",
"2025-01-01",
"2025-05-26",
"2025-07-04",
"2025-09-01",
"2025-11-27",
"2025-12-25",
"2026-01-01",
"2026-05-25"
],
"primary": "R1"
},
"registered_at": "2026-11-12T19:56:25-0500",
"registrant": "reproduction agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon",
"sha256": "a328718a0a0626bbf09fe1fcfbcb948f6ca0fb7030ecf9f312f8bb4677b79933",
"statement": "The MMR Fiscal 2026 values of average yellow-taxi travel speed in the Manhattan CBD (6.9 mph in FY25 and 6.5 mph in FY26) can be recomputed from TLC yellow taxi trip records within 0.2 mph under the primary reading of the unstated parts of the method.",
"target": {
"agency": "NYC Mayor's Office of Operations (indicator owner: NYC DOT, Division of Planning and Sustainability, Congestion Mitigation)",
"data_access": "open",
"data_used": "Not named in the report. Assumed: TLC yellow taxi trip records (NYC Open Data rwwi-khbc for 2024, irx2-vgm4 for 2025; TLC monthly parquet files for July 2023 to June 2026, which include January to June 2026), with TLC taxi zones (8meu-9t5y) and the MTA CBD taxi zone list (yfdc-w5jh). DOT may instead use GPS traces or a vendor feed that is not public.",
"date": "September 2026",
"definition": "'The average speed of yellow taxis traveling with passengers between the hours of 8AM-6PM, Monday-Friday, in Manhattan's Central Business District (CBD), excluding all major US holidays. The CBD covers the entire area south of 60th Street.' City fiscal years run July to June (FY25 = 1 Jul 2024 to 30 Jun 2025; FY26 = 1 Jul 2025 to 30 Jun 2026).",
"location": "DOT performance indicator table, p. 349; indicator definition, p. 256 of the definitions volume",
"number": {
"FY22": 8.4,
"FY23": 7.8,
"FY24": 6.9,
"FY25": 6.9,
"FY26": 6.5,
"registered_targets": "FY25 = 6.9 and FY26 = 6.5 (primary); FY24 = 6.9 (secondary)",
"unit": "mph"
},
"report": "Mayor's Management Report, Fiscal 2026, Department of Transportation chapter",
"url": "https://www.nyc.gov/assets/operations/downloads/pdf/mmr2026/dot.pdf",
"url_definitions": "https://www.nyc.gov/assets/operations/downloads/pdf/mmr2026/dot_idf.pdf"
}
},
"registration_commit": {
"commit": "928573e47944ef8cc17ce9463528a2a3f542c029",
"committed_at": "2026-11-12T19:56:25-05:00"
},
"registration_file_sha256": "effd9525987d5ae6252c362628d84ca719507bf32a2c59d59e4b9ff677e29550",
"registration_path": "claims/registered/repro-mmr-cbd-speed.json",
"registration_sha256": "a328718a0a0626bbf09fe1fcfbcb948f6ca0fb7030ecf9f312f8bb4677b79933",
"registration_text": "{\n \"id\": \"repro-mmr-cbd-speed\",\n \"kind\": \"reproduction\",\n \"target\": {\n \"report\": \"Mayor's Management Report, Fiscal 2026, Department of Transportation chapter\",\n \"agency\": \"NYC Mayor's Office of Operations (indicator owner: NYC DOT, Division of Planning and Sustainability, Congestion Mitigation)\",\n \"date\": \"September 2026\",\n \"url\": \"https://www.nyc.gov/assets/operations/downloads/pdf/mmr2026/dot.pdf\",\n \"url_definitions\": \"https://www.nyc.gov/assets/operations/downloads/pdf/mmr2026/dot_idf.pdf\",\n \"location\": \"DOT performance indicator table, p. 349; indicator definition, p. 256 of the definitions volume\",\n \"number\": {\n \"FY22\": 8.4,\n \"FY23\": 7.8,\n \"FY24\": 6.9,\n \"FY25\": 6.9,\n \"FY26\": 6.5,\n \"unit\": \"mph\",\n \"registered_targets\": \"FY25 = 6.9 and FY26 = 6.5 (primary); FY24 = 6.9 (secondary)\"\n },\n \"definition\": \"'The average speed of yellow taxis traveling with passengers between the hours of 8AM-6PM, Monday-Friday, in Manhattan's Central Business District (CBD), excluding all major US holidays. The CBD covers the entire area south of 60th Street.' City fiscal years run July to June (FY25 = 1 Jul 2024 to 30 Jun 2025; FY26 = 1 Jul 2025 to 30 Jun 2026).\",\n \"data_used\": \"Not named in the report. Assumed: TLC yellow taxi trip records (NYC Open Data rwwi-khbc for 2024, irx2-vgm4 for 2025; TLC monthly parquet files for July 2023 to June 2026, which include January to June 2026), with TLC taxi zones (8meu-9t5y) and the MTA CBD taxi zone list (yfdc-w5jh). DOT may instead use GPS traces or a vendor feed that is not public.\",\n \"data_access\": \"open\"\n },\n \"statement\": \"The MMR Fiscal 2026 values of average yellow-taxi travel speed in the Manhattan CBD (6.9 mph in FY25 and 6.5 mph in FY26) can be recomputed from TLC yellow taxi trip records within 0.2 mph under the primary reading of the unstated parts of the method.\",\n \"graph_evidence\": [],\n \"literature\": [\n {\n \"citation\": \"NYC DOT (2019). New York City Mobility Report.\",\n \"doi\": null,\n \"finding\": \"DOT has computed CBD travel speeds from taxi data in earlier reports; the trip-record method is not documented in the MMR.\",\n \"data_access\": \"open\"\n },\n {\n \"citation\": \"MTA. CBD Taxi and For-Hire Vehicle Speeds: Beginning October 2019 (data.ny.gov 6p29-6xqn).\",\n \"doi\": null,\n \"finding\": \"Monthly zonal speed for the CBD from TLC records; used here as a cross-check, not as the target.\",\n \"data_access\": \"open\"\n }\n ],\n \"prediction\": {\n \"direction\": \"0\",\n \"magnitude\": \"Tolerance: the reproduced value is within 0.2 mph of the stated value for FY25 (6.9) and for FY26 (6.5). The stated values are rounded to 0.1 mph, so 0.2 mph allows for rounding plus a small difference of method.\",\n \"support_if\": \"Under the primary reading R1, |FY25 - 6.9| <= 0.2 and |FY26 - 6.5| <= 0.2 (verdict confirmed).\",\n \"refute_if\": \"No registered reading R1 to R9 gives both FY25 and FY26 within 0.2 mph (verdict contested). If some readings other than R1 reproduce both and R1 does not, or R1 reproduces one year only, the verdict is unsettled.\",\n \"secondary\": \"(a) The FY25 to FY26 change, stated as -0.4 mph (-5.8%), is reproduced within 0.2 mph under R1. (b) FY24 (6.9) within 0.2 mph under R1. These are reported, and do not decide the verdict.\"\n },\n \"readings\": {\n \"primary\": \"R1\",\n \"R1\": \"Trips with pickup AND drop-off in the 38 MTA CBD taxi zones (yfdc-w5jh: 4, 12, 13, 45, 48, 50, 68, 79, 87, 88, 90, 100, 107, 113, 114, 125, 137, 144, 148, 158, 161, 162, 163, 164, 170, 186, 209, 211, 224, 229, 230, 231, 232, 233, 234, 246, 249, 261); pickup time 08:00:00 to 17:59:59 local, Monday to Friday; the 11 US federal holidays (observed dates) excluded; trip filter F1; speed = total trip_distance / total trip time (ratio of sums) over all qualifying trips in the fiscal year; no passenger_count filter (every trip record is a paid passenger trip).\",\n \"R2\": \"As R1, but the arithmetic mean of per-trip speeds.\",\n \"R3\": \"As R1, but the median of per-trip speeds.\",\n \"R4\": \"As R1, but pickup in the CBD with drop-off anywhere.\",\n \"R5\": \"As R1, but pickup or drop-off in the CBD.\",\n \"R6\": \"As R1, but filter F0 (minimal) instead of F1.\",\n \"R7\": \"As R1, but filter F2 (strict) instead of F1.\",\n \"R8\": \"As R1, but only passenger_count >= 1 (records with 0 or null passengers dropped), and only the six major holidays excluded.\",\n \"R9\": \"As R1, but the fiscal-year value is the unweighted mean of the twelve monthly ratio-of-sums values.\",\n \"filters\": {\n \"F0\": \"trip_distance > 0, duration > 0, speed < 100 mph\",\n \"F1\": \"0 < trip_distance <= 50 miles, 60 s <= duration <= 3 h, 0.5 <= speed <= 50 mph\",\n \"F2\": \"0.2 <= trip_distance <= 20 miles, 120 s <= duration <= 90 min, 1 <= speed <= 35 mph\"\n },\n \"holidays_federal_observed\": [\n \"2023-07-04\",\n \"2023-09-04\",\n \"2023-10-09\",\n \"2023-11-10\",\n \"2023-11-23\",\n \"2023-12-25\",\n \"2024-01-01\",\n \"2024-01-15\",\n \"2024-02-19\",\n \"2024-05-27\",\n \"2024-06-19\",\n \"2024-07-04\",\n \"2024-09-02\",\n \"2024-10-14\",\n \"2024-11-11\",\n \"2024-11-28\",\n \"2024-12-25\",\n \"2025-01-01\",\n \"2025-01-20\",\n \"2025-02-17\",\n \"2025-05-26\",\n \"2025-06-19\",\n \"2025-07-04\",\n \"2025-09-01\",\n \"2025-10-13\",\n \"2025-11-11\",\n \"2025-11-27\",\n \"2025-12-25\",\n \"2026-01-01\",\n \"2026-01-19\",\n \"2026-02-16\",\n \"2026-05-25\",\n \"2026-06-19\"\n ],\n \"holidays_major6\": [\n \"2023-07-04\",\n \"2023-09-04\",\n \"2023-11-23\",\n \"2023-12-25\",\n \"2024-01-01\",\n \"2024-05-27\",\n \"2024-07-04\",\n \"2024-09-02\",\n \"2024-11-28\",\n \"2024-12-25\",\n \"2025-01-01\",\n \"2025-05-26\",\n \"2025-07-04\",\n \"2025-09-01\",\n \"2025-11-27\",\n \"2025-12-25\",\n \"2026-01-01\",\n \"2026-05-25\"\n ],\n \"fiscal_year_assignment\": \"by pickup date; trips whose pickup timestamp falls outside the file's month are dropped\"\n },\n \"plan\": \"Data: TLC yellow taxi monthly parquet files for July 2023 to June 2026 (36 files from d37ci6vzurychx.cloudfront.net/trip-data/, cited by URL, Last-Modified and ETag), read with duckdb and kept in ~/opt/nyc-concordance/ outside Dropbox. Socrata copies rwwi-khbc (2024) and irx2-vgm4 (2025) are queried through concord/socrata.py for a monthly check of trip count and summed trip_distance under the R1 zone, hour, weekday and holiday conditions, so that the parquet files are shown to match the open-data copies. Compute FY24, FY25 and FY26 under R1 to R9. Cross-check: the MTA monthly CBD zonal speed (6p29-6xqn, data.ny.gov) averaged over the same fiscal years, descriptive only. Reconciliation with mob-crz-traffic (zone speeds +5.7% against the rest of the city) and the MTA's +4%: monthly R1 series July 2023 to June 2026 for the CBD and for trips within Manhattan north of 60th Street, calendar 2024 against 2025, and the split of FY25 into its untolled (Jul-Dec 2024) and tolled (Jan-Jun 2025) halves. These are descriptive and do not decide the verdict. Figure: monthly CBD speed under R1 and R2 with the MMR fiscal-year values drawn as steps, in figures/reproduction/.\",\n \"alternatives\": [\n \"DOT uses GPS traces or a probe-vehicle feed (not trip records), so trip-record speeds differ in level\",\n \"DOT uses a different zone set or a different time rule (trip wholly within 8AM-6PM)\",\n \"DOT averages differently (mean of trip speeds, mean of monthly values, or a segment-weighted mean)\",\n \"TLC revisions to the trip files since DOT computed the figure\"\n ],\n \"prior\": 0.35,\n \"registrant\": \"reproduction agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon\",\n \"registered_at\": \"2026-11-12T19:56:25-0500\",\n \"sha256\": \"a328718a0a0626bbf09fe1fcfbcb948f6ca0fb7030ecf9f312f8bb4677b79933\"\n}",
"statement": "The MMR Fiscal 2026 values of average yellow-taxi travel speed in the Manhattan CBD (6.9 mph in FY25 and 6.5 mph in FY26) can be recomputed from TLC yellow taxi trip records within 0.2 mph under the primary reading of the unstated parts of the method."
}History in this collection
- addedv1.0.0Nov 14, 2026this version