97 claims, 96 outcomes, 91 revisions; register at 30c90c1bd3b1

284 records0 files2.7 MiB total3 types
via nyc-concordance/underlay_exportNov 14, 2026ulv3:9d878b52aa00…ark:12345/ulcb4ksbc7h2v96n.v1.1.0
idkindstatementregistered_atregistration_sha256registration_file_sha256registration_pathhas_outcomelineageregistrationregistration_textoutcomeprereg_branchpriorregistrantregistration_commitreplicationsupersedes
afford-gentrification-prevalenceconfirmationAmong the 22 New York sub-borough areas with the lowest median gross rent in 2000, a minority (4 to 11) had both rent growth and growth in the share of college graduates above the city's by 2022-2024,…2026-11-13T07:47:06-0500fa3c20066db90e238edf57fbc75937cd481410e3747859490e78ae69235a501e44ef86f78b42287cd16b81870ab21d914043614de31988416f31f6253c82f353claims/registered/afford-gentrification-prevalence.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"d","class_meaning":"the outcome data were read for this claim before registration","classes":["d"],"early_sources":[{"class":…{"already_seen":"Read before registration: the 2000 values of every indicator for the 55 sub-borough areas and the city (rent, income, college share, poverty, population), which fix the low-start grou…{ "id": "afford-gentrification-prevalence", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Among the 22 New York sub-borough areas with the lowest median gross rent in 2000, a minority (4 to 11) had both re…afford-gentrification-prevalence{"name":"prereg/afford-gentrification-prevalence","sha":"f4d98390508380bfc4954c3091e8d4695f8aa346"}0.6Claude (affordability agent){"commit":"584e57e3a7c546b2c87aa670be25ecc539ee0e99","committed_at":"2026-11-13T08:05:56-05:00"}——
afford-poor-count-shiftconfirmationAmong the 22 low-rent sub-borough areas of 2000, the number of residents below the poverty line fell more between 2000 and 2022-2024 in the areas that gentrified (as defined in afford-gentrification-p…2026-11-13T07:47:06-050048a9801226fd5e68c65363e8728563631b39983abda37e120af9b668f3515aa324e0a14398397e7d66fef039100c476cf12d7fda23fea88f670c0cd146688371claims/registered/afford-poor-count-shift.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"e","class_meaning":"cannot tell","classes":["e"],"early_sources":[{"class":"e","dataset":"file","evidence":"Same workbook, wh…{"already_seen":"Read before registration: the 2000 values of every indicator for the 55 sub-borough areas and the city (rent, income, college share, poverty, population), which fix the low-start grou…{ "id": "afford-poor-count-shift", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Among the 22 low-rent sub-borough areas of 2000, the number of residents below the poverty line fell more between 2000 and 2…afford-poor-count-shift{"name":"prereg/afford-poor-count-shift","sha":"e2aff5c758ca8ec86504c03c5d234da787224f48"}0.5Claude (affordability agent){"commit":"584e57e3a7c546b2c87aa670be25ecc539ee0e99","committed_at":"2026-11-13T08:05:56-05:00"}——
all-boats-trees-rentconfirmationAcross New York City census tracts, a larger gain in living street trees between the 2005 and 2015 street tree censuses is followed by a faster rise in median gross rent between ACS 2008-12 and ACS 20…2026-11-13T07:46:53-050004c757287a2a6502078696eb6e4e13a790d502c3be954368f8f44ed6572f25b853e81665b089a4acabd371afb8bc2b494e9ec876c03350f86bd27776517bad91claims/registered/all-boats-trees-rent.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"29b…{"alternatives":["MillionTreesNYC (2007-2015) directed planting to low-canopy, poorer neighbourhoods, several of which gentrified for other reasons. This would produce a positive slope without any eff…{ "id": "all-boats-trees-rent", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Across New York City census tracts, a larger gain in living street trees between the 2005 and 2015 street tree censuses is foll…all-boats-trees-rent{"name":"prereg/all-boats-trees-rent","sha":"f960e5d68ecf34b7da5bbb8ac20a6c8601a78639"}—Claude (agent, all-boats task), 13 November 2026{"commit":"479e77abb8faa17835f8f6201f39b0305b64220b","committed_at":"2026-11-13T08:15:25-05:00"}——
bridge-crz-crash-linkbridgeResearch link for the congestion-pricing bridge: on urban roads, injury crashes change with mean speed as (v1/v0)^E with E about 1.2 (Elvik 2009), and with traffic volume with an elasticity of about 0…2026-11-12T16:04:49-05006e399c611dee95ac83ebd0e067fc83ffb98e77fa42a44c39cba646e344bab30bdee50b89f4c9f58398e6c0228ced0697f7de7acf87a5022f8e8e7d8aa07813dfclaims/registered/bridge-crz-crash-link.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["At network speeds of 8 to 9 mph, the power model may not apply: crash risk in congested streets depends on conflicts (turns, double parking, pedestrians crossing between stopped cars…{ "id": "bridge-crz-crash-link", "kind": "bridge", "statement": "Research link for the congestion-pricing bridge: on urban roads, injury crashes change with mean speed as (v1/v0)^E with E about 1.2…bridge-crz-crash-link——Claude (bridges agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"04c828fc3395e1179fc209590ba0603b39cbb8d6","committed_at":"2026-11-12T16:04:49-05:00"}——
bridge-crz-ems-travelbridgeAfter the congestion toll began, the mean travel time of ambulances to incidents in the Congestion Relief Zone during peak toll hours changed, relative to the rest of the city, by the amount composed …2026-11-13T08:05:02-0500ff1fa71925fff2373857af9c2c593cee5a8ad3cdc7c2bf5a495ef3eb30ceb3eb589b8ed60ba725a60f843db8c8ed0dfb03f1a3aa706377b77c055bb48a8190e9claims/registered/bridge-crz-ems-travel.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"b","class_meaning":"a design, power or calibration read, pre-period data, or metadata","classes":["b"],"early_sources":[{"cla…{"alternatives":["Mount Sinai Beth Israel hospital (First Avenue at 16th Street, inside the zone) closed in 2025; longer transports keep units busy and can lengthen travel to the next call in the zone…{ "id": "bridge-crz-ems-travel", "kind": "bridge", "statement": "After the congestion toll began, the mean travel time of ambulances to incidents in the Congestion Relief Zone during peak toll hour…bridge-crz-ems-travel{"name":"prereg/bridge-crz-ems-travel","sha":"5647a1d405e58d639c26cfeaceb2558ea11eacf3"}0.45Claude (agent, congestion tradeoffs task), 13 November 2026{"commit":"1819abd64c30d70ce34ba251873f41660e946536","committed_at":"2026-11-13T08:44:57-05:00"}——
bridge-crz-injury-crashesbridgeComposed from faster speeds (mob-crz-traffic) and fewer vehicles in the Congestion Relief Zone, with the research link between speed, volume and crashes (bridge-crz-crash-link), the predicted change i…2026-11-12T16:04:50-050000214aa37b7048fd67592e270a507ea967e22918bb76602f42ab8388507b0221168cdbe647e1126dd70b2088d4497bc6593121c23f04df63e0710b24055764d5claims/registered/bridge-crz-injury-crashes.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"srx…{"alternatives":["Pre-existing differential trend in the zone (tested by the 2024 placebo).","Changes in crash reporting or geocoding that differ between Manhattan and the rest of the city (share of c…{ "id": "bridge-crz-injury-crashes", "kind": "bridge", "statement": "Composed from faster speeds (mob-crz-traffic) and fewer vehicles in the Congestion Relief Zone, with the research link between s…bridge-crz-injury-crashes—0.45Claude (bridges agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"29033c729b1930f32c87ed0b1cd47a0e5dc2a6e2","committed_at":"2026-11-12T16:04:50-05:00"}——
bridge-crz-injury-crashes-v2bridgeRe-analysis of bridge-crz-injury-crashes with a comparison area that shares the zone's geocoding regime: the change in injury crashes in the Congestion Relief Zone relative to Manhattan north of 60th …2026-11-12T19:31:52-05009266a132f4f01ea51d70bfde147523bd150ac7718f7322c640fda00668b8b71c6729364f4cb88c552d271516ae2cd004892963104a3044a34f353a50c67ee903claims/registered/bridge-crz-injury-crashes-v2.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"srx…{"alternatives":["Differential geocoding between the zone and the north area (bounded by B1-B4).","Spillover: traffic diverted from the zone onto streets north of 60th St would raise crashes there and…{ "id": "bridge-crz-injury-crashes-v2", "kind": "bridge", "reanalysis_of": "bridge-crz-injury-crashes", "critique": "critique/bridge-crz-injury-crashes.md", "statement": "Re-analysis of bridge-cr…bridge-crz-injury-crashes-v2—0.05Claude (bridges agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"ce3586a3d421f9ea86a1e5f7da48eba9d2ed0b5c","committed_at":"2026-11-12T19:31:56-05:00"}——
bridge-heat-shootings-emsbridgeComposed from heat and shootings (heat-shootings, NYPD) and the share of EMS gunshot dispatches that are shooting victims (bridge-shot-ems-link), daily FDNY EMS dispatches for gunshot wounds rise with…2026-11-12T16:04:50-0500bda255d3ebffd6189ea84b6060c0e85675e809fee6bcbdbb17a4a6281ff11099c880deea51a7d1e73ff43134e790890f5b9fb45df061727bdcfb42b4fe68e976claims/registered/bridge-heat-shootings-ems.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a","b"],"early_sources":[{"class":"b","dataset":…{"alternatives":["Fireworks around 4 July are reported as shots; holidays are in the model, and the warm-season sensitivity checks the rest.","EMS call-type coding changed over the period; year terms …{ "id": "bridge-heat-shootings-ems", "kind": "bridge", "statement": "Composed from heat and shootings (heat-shootings, NYPD) and the share of EMS gunshot dispatches that are shooting victims (bridg…bridge-heat-shootings-ems—0.6Claude (bridges agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"e783221b5d7cc4d6d50238ac6a32ba600bfd162b","committed_at":"2026-11-12T16:04:50-05:00"}{"built_at":"2026-11-13T22:57:33-0500","checked_at":"2026-11-13T22:57:33-0500","decides":"endpoint IRR compatible with the composed prediction 1.099 (1.049 to 1.148), |z| < 1.96","deciding_number":"ci…—
bridge-shot-ems-linkbridgeSecond link of the heat-violence bridge: FDNY EMS dispatches with initial call type SHOT rise with the day's NYPD shooting incidents, by about one dispatch per incident.2026-11-12T16:04:50-0500afc8a2d6eada92cd10111a27ebad0449dffb259becd29c5d69118ebcbac018b2de5909ac3f8a1c227c7f06f402fd478b56ac2c65a4c071234a922c6aa98f47e8claims/registered/bridge-shot-ems-link.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"5uc…{"alternatives":["Many SHOT dispatches are reports of shots fired with no victim, so the intercept and the noise are large.","Multiple callers can create separate EMS incidents for one shooting."],"ch…{ "id": "bridge-shot-ems-link", "kind": "bridge", "statement": "Second link of the heat-violence bridge: FDNY EMS dispatches with initial call type SHOT rise with the day's NYPD shooting incidents,…bridge-shot-ems-link—0.7Claude (bridges agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"f012e8db54dd37d3f35446dcaede03394ba020e2","committed_at":"2026-11-12T16:04:50-05:00"}——
commute-fhv-subway-distanceconfirmationOutside Manhattan, New York City taxi zones whose residents live farther from a subway or Staten Island Railway station have more high-volume for-hire (app) pickups per resident in 2024, after adjusti…2026-11-12T16:24:52-0500f5c9850d08414a240736be26161839476b37c00b5839ed649dedca39db4561723cf3f4b8d21115f96e9ece1b61f530f1d75df1887d391170f44050def3f082dbclaims/registered/commute-fhv-subway-distance.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Car ownership: households far from the subway own cars and need fewer app trips (the no-vehicle sensitivity addresses this)","Non-resident demand: pickups count visitors and workers …{ "id": "commute-fhv-subway-distance", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Outside Manhattan, New York City taxi zones whose residents live farther from a subway or Staten Island Railway station …commute-fhv-subway-distance—0.35commuting agent (Claude Opus 5.5), 12 Nov 2026{"commit":"eb1e22f760a9fb9c544932de25c7b0363d66bc8c","committed_at":"2026-11-12T16:24:52-05:00"}——
commute-time-depressionconfirmationAcross New York City's 42 UHF neighbourhoods, a longer mean travel time to work goes with a higher age-adjusted share of adults with depression, after adjusting for poverty and walking access to the s…2026-11-12T16:24:52-05003908e52e90ed062cd9d24cc967a43cb9af43d0811cec9687338eb50675c352bc6a227baa8bfb054b6dd7097215c6e7436c59eb1f0ab16c164715d63f792502b1claims/registered/commute-time-depression.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Poverty and income: long commutes in New York are concentrated in lower-income outer-borough neighbourhoods","Transit access: neighbourhoods far from the subway have long bus commute…{ "id": "commute-time-depression", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Across New York City's 42 UHF neighbourhoods, a longer mean travel time to work goes with a higher age-adjusted share of adu…commute-time-depression—0.25commuting agent (Claude Opus 5.5), 12 Nov 2026{"commit":"eb1e22f760a9fb9c544932de25c7b0363d66bc8c","committed_at":"2026-11-12T16:24:52-05:00"}——
construction-2022-rush-units-2027confirmationAt least 80 percent of the housing units in new-building jobs permitted in the first half of 2022, ahead of the 421-a expiry, will have a completion date on or before 30 June 2027, as DCP's statement …2026-11-12T18:10:22-0500da4f76cd5a54cc6522763e7ba856b72ce1931b3f5ae93471d75be0885ea9453690064ac672b325d03e466c0f0c18171aa68d7b452c5439719b455d4a8d2033d0claims/registered/construction-2022-rush-units-2027.jsonfalse{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Placeholder filings: some jobs were permitted only to vest 421-a eligibility and were not meant to start soon, lowering the share without any change in how ordinary projects finish",…{ "id": "construction-2022-rush-units-2027", "kind": "confirmation", "supersedes": null, "follows": "construction-four-year-completion (settle condition 2 and its first research_needed entry)", "…——0.25Claude (prospective-registration agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"d7eb381b20c3a1a00336dac15e4b657065b685c0","committed_at":"2026-11-12T18:10:22-05:00"}——
construction-aerial-triangulationbridgeAerial photographs (USDA NAIP) give a third, independent record of whether permitted new buildings were built: for a random sample of NB jobs first permitted 2018-2020, visible change on the lot betwe…2026-11-12T15:14:19-0500b42be119e44d67ed12a7a931fdb8041c865bbcf97b3332de4bb3df303a9738e6bc44504d7ae4352b06f40b867ff60f49472aa8409266be8bb7fb5959446313a3claims/registered/construction-aerial-triangulation.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Seasonal and sun-angle differences in NAIP make unchanged lots look changed","Tall neighbouring buildings lean over small lots in an orthophoto and hide them","Interior gut renovatio…{ "id": "construction-aerial-triangulation", "kind": "bridge", "statement": "Aerial photographs (USDA NAIP) give a third, independent record of whether permitted new buildings were built: for a ran…construction-aerial-triangulation—0.45Claude (construction agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"2a0a43902986996647ae72174b3ecc906e59d2e1","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:14:20-05:00"}——
construction-four-year-completionconfirmationThe share of NYC new-building jobs that reach a certificate of occupancy within four years of first permit matches the Department of City Planning's statement that 80 to 90 percent of permitted projec…2026-11-12T15:14:19-05008164e034d6847d622f5349c88037a7b6be051bb2f2d01e9c6886ec387c13ce8909008ab627302d6cf0b98d6eff8bd70c49052fe9cf0f39174427dc9cd8d7df86claims/registered/construction-four-year-completion.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["DCP counts projects or units, and units weight large projects that finish more reliably than small one- and two-family jobs","Job numbers change between filing systems (BIS to DOB NO…{ "id": "construction-four-year-completion", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "The share of NYC new-building jobs that reach a certificate of occupancy within four years of first permit matches…construction-four-year-completion—0.35Claude (construction agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"eb942af9f2284b40f8f7a1ab1e7568121e816cf9","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:14:20-05:00"}——
construction-permit-funnelconfirmationIn New York City, counts of new-building (NB) permit rows overstate new buildings: each NB job carries several permit rows, and fewer jobs reach a certificate of occupancy and a recorded year built th…2026-11-12T15:14:19-0500443fc73d3f520619115c56c1a222658021e30f012b0a8da0467e47d56aaf7c16da0cf791a015b8188debbc304e8c93f3dc389c9c53fa591b676183d5b68e50acclaims/registered/construction-permit-funnel.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Jobs that are superseded or refiled under a new job number (the building is built, under another job)","CO records missing from open data or issued under a different job number (temp…{ "id": "construction-permit-funnel", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "In New York City, counts of new-building (NB) permit rows overstate new buildings: each NB job carries several permit row…construction-permit-funnel—0.75Claude (construction agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"0c48949aa51677b9f194c5d67a0608b4a46a9574","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:14:19-05:00"}——
construction-sheds-outnumber-nbconfirmationOn a given day, the construction a person sees on NYC streets is mostly not new buildings: active sidewalk-shed permits outnumber active new-building jobs, and most sheds stand on lots without an acti…2026-11-12T15:14:19-050068c5ba696bdd755dd9de33aa5fc2cb00428b1c7187e3bb6c3327d843053f0a586496a1ec1dbbd32bb57d749f02bb9ce07c179c8f3bb3a489204786e9ec6c194bclaims/registered/construction-sheds-outnumber-nb.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Permit 'active' status overstates sheds actually standing (sheds removed before the permit expires) or understates them (sheds standing on expired permits)","Sheds per job differ (on…{ "id": "construction-sheds-outnumber-nb", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "On a given day, the construction a person sees on NYC streets is mostly not new buildings: active sidewalk-shed perm…construction-sheds-outnumber-nb—0.6Claude (construction agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"58226fd747bacc5d46a11fd3851a9de727a4d56a","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:14:20-05:00"}——
construction2-rows-per-job-dobnowconfirmationIn DOB NOW, each new-building job first permitted in 2021-2022 carries several work-permit rows by November 2026, so counts of permit rows overstate jobs in the current system as in the legacy one.2026-11-12T15:59:34-05009216924adaba1c88a903dc6aa76df0af4f2114c3c92cb5d88cca7ff720cfdc78573fb02f6a349e41531e00c91b2150b5075f1ba8cf49b42b8bb96b73ccbd999bclaims/registered/construction2-rows-per-job-dobnow.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"b","class_meaning":"a design, power or calibration read, pre-period data, or metadata","classes":["b"],"early_sources":[{"cla…{"alternatives":["DOB NOW records renewals by updating a permit row rather than adding one, lowering the count","DOB NOW may issue one permit covering several work types, lowering the count","Right-ce…{ "id": "construction2-rows-per-job-dobnow", "kind": "confirmation", "supersedes": null, "replicates": "construction-permit-funnel (exploratory lifetime rows per job by cohort, 7.0-10.3 for 2010-2…construction2-rows-per-job-dobnow—0.7Claude (construction replication agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"6159cf61b168c83473b7eaa56801faf7cedc5ff7","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:59:34-05:00"}——
construction2-rows-per-job-legacy-2000sconfirmationIn the legacy DOB permit table, each new-building job first permitted in 2000-2009 carries several permit rows over its life, so counts of NB permit rows overstate jobs, as they did for cohorts 2010-2…2026-11-12T15:59:34-05000b0ea50433c04323fb86056154dcb987304443ae4b083594ccc7ed01ce67fc52c909365e56a9864567d4cfdb3cc32aabcca9a7093df3ffaf800429480204bdafclaims/registered/construction2-rows-per-job-legacy-2000s.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"c","class_meaning":"a shared cache: the query was fetched for an earlier claim and holds this claim's outcome","classes":["c"…{"alternatives":["Jobs from the 2000s may have had fewer permit types (equipment and plumbing permits were split out differently), lowering rows without any change in buildings per job","The table may…{ "id": "construction2-rows-per-job-legacy-2000s", "kind": "confirmation", "supersedes": null, "replicates": "construction-permit-funnel (exploratory lifetime rows per job by cohort, 7.0-10.3 for …construction2-rows-per-job-legacy-2000s—0.6Claude (construction replication agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"6159cf61b168c83473b7eaa56801faf7cedc5ff7","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:59:34-05:00"}——
crz-storefront-vacancyconfirmationOne year after the congestion toll began, the share of storefronts vacant on 31 December 2025 in the Congestion Relief Zone had not risen relative to the rest of the city: the change from 31 December …2026-11-13T08:09:53-05004839a5367fdfd33a809aa3bcf910aa6e7dbeacc24f2b4bbbec45a5cf517ee070eeffa2467a5769ef0533b2658330b3a406e9d8049dd924ef9f977a34c64d34f5claims/registered/crz-storefront-vacancy.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"b","class_meaning":"a design, power or calibration read, pre-period data, or metadata","classes":["b"],"early_sources":[{"cla…{"alternatives":["Continued recovery of Manhattan retail from the pandemic peak in vacancy, which lowers zone vacancy whatever the toll does.","Office attendance and tourism in the zone, which changed…{ "id": "crz-storefront-vacancy", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "One year after the congestion toll began, the share of storefronts vacant on 31 December 2025 in the Congestion Relief Zone h…crz-storefront-vacancy{"name":"prereg/crz-storefront-vacancy","sha":"f2a181c5e3f75a7e5c9fd14b8fa1da6ed16c116d"}0.6Claude (agent, congestion tradeoffs task), 13 November 2026{"commit":"1819abd64c30d70ce34ba251873f41660e946536","committed_at":"2026-11-13T08:44:57-05:00"}——
ems-hospital-turnaround-waitconfirmationIn New York City, on days when ambulances spend longer at hospitals after transporting a patient, callers wait longer for an ambulance to be assigned, holding the day's call volume, the day of week an…2026-11-13T11:54:58-05008441e4128a55fa566516f03ec6b2992030e717cba3c8197f4682524cfc46e173d119d143a0c2c2b32c718493432d6335bcb54cfa21bc1c9dfabf98fdea66b310claims/registered/ems-hospital-turnaround-wait.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Common daily shock: heat, flu or other surges crowd emergency departments and raise ambulance demand together, beyond what the call count captures; the previous-day model and the sev…{ "id": "ems-hospital-turnaround-wait", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "In New York City, on days when ambulances spend longer at hospitals after transporting a patient, callers wait longer f…ems-hospital-turnaround-wait{"name":"prereg/ems-hospital-turnaround-wait","sha":"be7f692245a7be72156b1d7907bd1bc064346f0f"}0.6health-gaps agent (Claude), 13 Nov 2026{"commit":"be7f692245a7be72156b1d7907bd1bc064346f0f","committed_at":"2026-11-13T11:54:58-05:00"}——
ems-taxi-2026-onsetconfirmationWeek by week from July 2025 to September 2026, the change in Manhattan ambulance travel time against the same week a year earlier tracks the change in taxi pace, and the January 2026 step in ambulance…2026-11-13T13:27:12-0500e9cd995a8a597b39aa3bd25d9f9a731985bd20cefd9f9665bc8e9b21a616756d9e1006556503d556c61e6889df8d371a1d53c8828a32419b15c7d7a8d9afc60fclaims/registered/ems-taxi-2026-onset.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"c","class_meaning":"a shared cache: the query was fetched for an earlier claim and holds this claim's outcome","classes":["c"…{"alternatives":["Fewer ambulance unit-hours (MMR: in-service hours per day 8,891 in FY22 to 8,109 in FY26), so the nearest free unit is farther away (a distance effect, not traffic)","Hospital closur…{ "id": "ems-taxi-2026-onset", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Week by week from July 2025 to September 2026, the change in Manhattan ambulance travel time against the same week a year earlie…ems-taxi-2026-onset{"name":"prereg/ems-taxi-2026-onset","sha":"d75fa5e45a373186fbb58bbf701634078996d8b1"}0.25claude (ems_response thread){"commit":"d75fa5e45a373186fbb58bbf701634078996d8b1","committed_at":"2026-11-13T13:27:13-05:00"}——
ems-traffic-hourly-elasticityconfirmationWithin a day, Manhattan ambulance travel time rises in hours when yellow-taxi trips in the same area are slower than usual, with an elasticity between 0.3 and 0.9, and taxi pace a week later does not …2026-11-13T13:27:12-0500ad3404a9d7090050cd7910f3742ac2d8b150b6194d815eced9cf77aab7a312fa7a233e3087417cbb578bfbea8e28dfc73eb32d059fe4a196a951d4034bd9b804claims/registered/ems-traffic-hourly-elasticity.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"c","class_meaning":"a shared cache: the query was fetched for an earlier claim and holds this claim's outcome","classes":["c"…{"alternatives":["Fewer ambulance unit-hours (MMR: in-service hours per day 8,891 in FY22 to 8,109 in FY26), so the nearest free unit is farther away (a distance effect, not traffic)","Hospital closur…{ "id": "ems-traffic-hourly-elasticity", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Within a day, Manhattan ambulance travel time rises in hours when yellow-taxi trips in the same area are slower than u…ems-traffic-hourly-elasticity{"name":"prereg/ems-traffic-hourly-elasticity","sha":"d75fa5e45a373186fbb58bbf701634078996d8b1"}0.8claude (ems_response thread){"commit":"d75fa5e45a373186fbb58bbf701634078996d8b1","committed_at":"2026-11-13T13:27:13-05:00"}——
ems-traffic-share-2019-2026conflictSlower traffic accounts for less than half of the rise in Manhattan life-threatening ambulance travel time from January-September 2019 to January-September 2026, even if ambulance pace moved one for o…2026-11-13T13:27:12-0500d5ae4bc880e81dbf1075d0d6df0963bb730aa71f31a494104950158198bfe18031223f1c816c8027002b480e86d355caff4202a751c0edd29abcf139ff5a8444claims/registered/ems-traffic-share-2019-2026.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"c","class_meaning":"a shared cache: the query was fetched for an earlier claim and holds this claim's outcome","classes":["c"…{"alternatives":["Fewer ambulance unit-hours (MMR: in-service hours per day 8,891 in FY22 to 8,109 in FY26), so the nearest free unit is farther away (a distance effect, not traffic)","Hospital closur…{ "id": "ems-traffic-share-2019-2026", "kind": "conflict", "statement": "Slower traffic accounts for less than half of the rise in Manhattan life-threatening ambulance travel time from January-Sept…ems-traffic-share-2019-2026{"name":"prereg/ems-traffic-share-2019-2026","sha":"d75fa5e45a373186fbb58bbf701634078996d8b1"}0.8claude (ems_response thread){"commit":"d75fa5e45a373186fbb58bbf701634078996d8b1","committed_at":"2026-11-13T13:27:13-05:00"}{"built_at":"2026-11-13T22:57:21-0500","checked_at":"2026-11-13T22:57:21-0500","decides":"support_if: upper 95% limit of S1 below 0.5 and estimate within 0.05 to 0.45","deciding_number":"city_effect: …—
food-supermarket-diabetes-zctaconflictAcross New York City ZIP code areas, the number of supermarkets per resident does not predict adult hospital admissions for diabetes (age-sex standardised) once residential density, poverty, income an…2026-11-13T12:00:23-05007af9b8f8298e72630678ce3e796d6338e4a27db4a3fd984b8af08f9a605c8d36361449b306ce81bca4e5c7536e66a48039b5f64e4cb5475bf094894ca02bdf09claims/registered/food-supermarket-diabetes-zcta.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Reverse placement: supermarket chains locate by purchasing power, so supply follows income and density rather than causing health; adjustment for income and density addresses this on…{ "id": "food-supermarket-diabetes-zcta", "kind": "conflict", "statement": "Across New York City ZIP code areas, the number of supermarkets per resident does not predict adult hospital admissions f…food-supermarket-diabetes-zcta{"name":"prereg/food-supermarket-diabetes-zcta","sha":"d97489780d3225135daa115962fcd4b9fb9a8e71"}0.55health-gaps agent (Claude), 13 Nov 2026{"commit":"d97489780d3225135daa115962fcd4b9fb9a8e71","committed_at":"2026-11-13T12:00:23-05:00"}{"built_at":"2026-11-13T23:18:54-0500","checked_at":"2026-11-13T23:18:54-0500","decides":"support_if: primary ratio with 95% interval inside (0.90, 1.10) and estimate at or above 0.95","deciding_numbe…—
further-chinatown-shiftreproductionRecomputed from census tracts, Manhattan's Chinatown area lost about 22 percent of its non-Hispanic Asian and Pacific Islander residents between 2010 and 2020 (AALDEF: 52,613 to 41,024, with 2020 take…2026-11-12T20:25:17-0500c174b413a292e82799e78ae8ed86dd152036576f75d2ff607d43b42599177dc0fe3605d27106e865884a25b40d4a579207316ef42701aae53a0c70442e702311claims/registered/further-chinatown-shift.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Boundary: AALDEF's Chinatown is not an NTA union, so a different boundary (B2 narrower, B3 wider, or an unlisted line) changes the counts and the percentage change.","Measure: AALDEF…{ "id": "further-chinatown-shift", "kind": "reproduction", "target": { "report": "Mapping Chinatown: Displacement in Boston, New York City, and Philadelphia", "agency": "Asian American Legal De…further-chinatown-shift{"name":"prereg/further-chinatown-shift","sha":"67d4ab96e023344ea8afc7ff42dce2e79afddf33"}0.4Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"79c8946fe04d6715670ce17e3e67f604fc95a524","committed_at":"2026-11-12T20:25:17-05:00"}——
further-containers-rats-cd9confirmationAfter Manhattan Community District 9 became fully containerised (full service from 2 June 2025), 311 rat sightings there fell by more in the twelve months from June 2025 than in the adjacent districts…2026-11-12T20:24:12-05007bf2cdafd2d3633538f5f2c51977dc4aeaa3496ddcd0720192fabb95d92e4e8ff8f5b44841f7148787d653ff925b57d2f6fdf5c9520de3c810f8c706060405c6claims/registered/further-containers-rats-cd9.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Citywide 311 reporting fell for reasons unrelated to bins (attention, app changes, weather); a CD9 fall no larger than elsewhere counts against the causal sentence.","Spillover: rats…{ "id": "further-containers-rats-cd9", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "After Manhattan Community District 9 became fully containerised (full service from 2 June 2025), 311 rat sightings there…further-containers-rats-cd9{"name":"prereg/further-containers-rats-cd9","sha":"f4a8b2b78265fe0f85ce3b6b3d9c18cb5ea45c21"}0.3Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"6d74c65900d01f55c571162c4419856a85dbdcce","committed_at":"2026-11-12T20:24:13-05:00"}——
further-datacentre-share-manhattanconflictIn calendar year 2024, data-centre use is a smaller share of Manhattan's benchmarked electricity than the 4.4 percent that data centres were reported to use of total US electricity in 2023: the upper-…2026-11-12T20:25:46-050086eda5d853b6cd7582e2d082098a36fe3cee568caf7a9c604fa85bc96d4a704b6b7ced682a7fe4795f6b045fc4525fea186e9ec6ed04e0c1c7ce4d72e3f393afclaims/registered/further-datacentre-share-manhattan.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"f","class_meaning":"no early read of city data (date-only or misparsed fetch time, or a published benchmark)","classes":["f"]…{"alternatives":["Colocation floors are reported under Office or Other rather than Data Center, so the use-type route (L1, L2, area share) understates and the whole-building route (U) overstates; U is…{ "id": "further-datacentre-share-manhattan", "kind": "conflict", "statement": "In calendar year 2024, data-centre use is a smaller share of Manhattan's benchmarked electricity than the 4.4 percent…further-datacentre-share-manhattan{"name":"prereg/further-datacentre-share-manhattan","sha":"6af48a3abef867e352f19d2d962ac0d02fe0f469"}0.7Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"f7ed2f98b8ab2991e79346e35b50e8e398ae1dc9","committed_at":"2026-11-12T20:25:55-05:00"}——
further-datacentre-share-manhattan-v2conflictIn calendar year 2024, the electricity allocated to data-centre use in Manhattan, estimated as reported IT site energy times a PUE of 1.4 to 2.0 (low figure) and, for named carrier hotels, the excess …2026-11-12T23:40:48-05005c4525d1aeea63752d791b55c347f466582630c49b79fc609de8fd5f01f8a91b83d2fefa5fa3bea9221e22abe975789185e96cf79a0e9298f51a1eb3b13866bdclaims/registered/further-datacentre-share-manhattan-v2.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"f","class_meaning":"no early read of city data (date-only or misparsed fetch time, or a published benchmark)","classes":["f"]…{"alternatives":["Tenants of carrier hotels meter their own electricity, so the landlord-reported figures (A cap and B) understate the data-centre load; the allocated share would then be a lower bound…{ "id": "further-datacentre-share-manhattan-v2", "kind": "conflict", "supersedes": "further-datacentre-share-manhattan", "statement": "In calendar year 2024, the electricity allocated to data-cent…further-datacentre-share-manhattan-v2{"name":"prereg/further-datacentre-share-manhattan-v2","sha":"88e5344dc7aee52ecf608cf654a988b2a91e0adf"}0.5Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"413d34119e1cbb4c1503dcd6ad7ac77c5b089d73","committed_at":"2026-11-12T23:40:54-05:00"}—further-datacentre-share-manhattan
further-repro-dsny-rat-sightingsreproductionThe citywide counts 25,230 (Dec 2023-Nov 2024) and 20,025 (Dec 2024-Nov 2025) in DSNY release 25-042 can be recomputed from 311 open data, within 1 percent each, under the primary reading of the unsta…2026-11-12T20:24:12-05004118fa13864020ab4ec3095df86d5d9bfd9d07a2384139dfcdb745ce7911f521ec2dcf5ab6e8d08b85dca5f8a702365126c55d0b3f817b1742af682ccdb0d2beclaims/registered/further-repro-dsny-rat-sightings.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["The city counts a different dataset or snapshot (e.g. a DSNY or 311 internal view)","Later reclassification or deletion of records changes counts"],"graph_evidence":[{"concepts":["tr…{ "id": "further-repro-dsny-rat-sightings", "kind": "reproduction", "target": { "report": "DSNY press release 25-042, New York's Strongest Delivered a Cleaner, More Sustainable City in 2025", "…further-repro-dsny-rat-sightings{"name":"prereg/further-repro-dsny-rat-sightings","sha":"6c242895799b7cc08801e6f717ec7a84e62463e3"}0.5Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"850ce0e2664f57d7a3853ad06f554030ce65859b","committed_at":"2026-11-12T20:24:13-05:00"}——
further-subway-crime-per-million-reproreproductionThe MTA Major Felonies table (yeek-jhmu) reproduces the Governor's figures: about 1.65 major felonies per million riders in 2025 and a fall of about 30% from 2021.2026-11-12T20:28:09-050096fcc59a82adf26b842bd04e914386e8906e5c3f9e48101cde0f61f391df52ca4f6a064f069d9a4042f0f441e38acac297dc61a3c6f733360d663bd1be6aaf34claims/registered/further-subway-crime-per-million-repro.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["The State's figure uses different months, agencies, a different rider count (ridership by trips rather than entries) or a different release of the table."],"disclosure_prior_looks":"…{ "id": "further-subway-crime-per-million-repro", "kind": "reproduction", "target": { "report": "Safer Subways: Governor Hochul announces subway crime on track to reach lowest levels in a generat…further-subway-crime-per-million-repro—0.6Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"acfbbf7fe1044c26e76be1988a69669ab9b38eea","committed_at":"2026-11-12T20:28:09-05:00"}——
further-subway-crime-per-ride-by-hourconflictPer fare entry, major felonies reported in the NYC subway in the hours 0-5 are at least three times as frequent as in the hours 10-16 in the 12 months to September 2026, and the 0-5 rate has not falle…2026-11-12T20:28:09-05009d4875fd8f4e1945fa7e212b3e18ba7ac5a02af347f67bdec23ffbad9b25100b2d80aa867d17eb9f01c2cde4ab167934039db81721c8b8fdee7dfbcbc216149fclaims/registered/further-subway-crime-per-ride-by-hour.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Reporting and coding: a change in how subway crimes are coded (premise) or reported by hour produces the pattern without a change in risk (placebo and S1, S2).","Composition of rider…{ "id": "further-subway-crime-per-ride-by-hour", "kind": "conflict", "statement": "Per fare entry, major felonies reported in the NYC subway in the hours 0-5 are at least three times as frequent as…further-subway-crime-per-ride-by-hour{"name":"prereg/further-subway-crime-per-ride-by-hour","sha":"79c5c3261a16d93b28ba2a2d825e99f83954ddb9"}0.35Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"acfbbf7fe1044c26e76be1988a69669ab9b38eea","committed_at":"2026-11-12T20:28:09-05:00"}——
further-tidal-flooding-311confirmationOn rain-free days, 311 street-flooding complaints from ZIP codes in the tidal-flood areas of New York City (Howard Beach, Broad Channel and the Rockaways, Red Hook, Coney Island) are more frequent on …2026-11-12T20:23:29-0500f7edaad6f0153133846782cbfcda9eb997e79212d3e68c13ca26f3e95b6b622867ebac34b72499b896a8938b27688dc0b31e25ffa5c3ea4ccd3b7305ab836261claims/registered/further-tidal-flooding-311.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Reports follow rainfall and sewer failure, not tide, so the true response to tide-only flooding is near zero because tidal nuisance flooding is brief, localised, expected by resident…{ "id": "further-tidal-flooding-311", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "On rain-free days, 311 street-flooding complaints from ZIP codes in the tidal-flood areas of New York City (Howard Beach,…further-tidal-flooding-311{"name":"prereg/further-tidal-flooding-311","sha":"153e2dcd9c1dddcfcda0b7a650491a4bb3a94805"}0.3Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"c3e48700b597ad047652e0801cf6a0f03e347e6f","committed_at":"2026-11-12T20:23:36-05:00"}——
further-tidal-flooding-trendconfirmationIn a held-out period (2010 to 2019), on dry days 311 street-flooding and catch-basin complaints from the low-lying coastal ZIP codes rise with the daily maximum water level at the Battery above a knot…2026-11-12T23:44:06-0500517759937d19637def545614ad12b6602797658a915567e7ab6799e9575efe786ee6dea3a3753fda142131545b637e23ca9c3da45e4671b44d018e8ba9db30caclaims/registered/further-tidal-flooding-trend.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"851…{"alternatives":["Reports follow rain that falls locally but not at the two airport gauges, and sewer surcharge after earlier rain, so a positive slope reflects weather and not tide.","Perigean spring…{ "id": "further-tidal-flooding-trend", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "In a held-out period (2010 to 2019), on dry days 311 street-flooding and catch-basin complaints from the low-lying coas…further-tidal-flooding-trend{"name":"prereg/further-tidal-flooding-trend","sha":"9ff568d395bba4664fd53c9696b3c4a5731ddcb8"}0.35Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"5fd01ba768e88801a5f5ee5d2ae9d796b2f9c356","committed_at":"2026-11-12T23:44:14-05:00"}{"built_at":"2026-11-13T23:01:49-0500","checked_at":"2026-11-13T23:01:49-0500","decides":"support_if: tidal-set interval lower limit above 1.00 and tidal-over-placebo ratio interval lower limit above …—
further-zonej-demand-growthconfirmationElectricity demand in New York City is growing: weather-normalised annual energy in NYISO Zone J (N.Y.C.) rose by more than 0.5 percent a year over 2015 to 2025, with a 95 percent interval that exclud…2026-11-12T20:23:09-050095fedd193355dacaffeff3c1938d44d485d09b756c545d8acdc7035a48356581290352741ce51f3c45689c0fae0eb642cfc18c1d8546ca9882f9d51f80e5f715claims/registered/further-zonej-demand-growth.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"f","class_meaning":"no early read of city data (date-only or misparsed fetch time, or a published benchmark)","classes":["f"]…{"alternatives":["Flat demand: efficiency, rooftop solar and weaker office occupancy offset electrification, so the weather-normalised trend is within about +-0.5 percent a year of zero.","Growth conf…{ "id": "further-zonej-demand-growth", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Electricity demand in New York City is growing: weather-normalised annual energy in NYISO Zone J (N.Y.C.) rose by more t…further-zonej-demand-growth{"name":"prereg/further-zonej-demand-growth","sha":"6b702dd8ac648f8f6cbb1817563a66b132749012"}0.2Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"15737cc037ecd84a8bee5a44dd5d4a19ec0aadc5","committed_at":"2026-11-12T20:23:09-05:00"}——
graph-concordance-matrixconfirmationAcross New York City's 42 UHF neighbourhoods, the sign of the correlation between two published indicators matches the majority sign of the System Public Graph's findings for the same pair of concepts…2026-11-12T22:49:55-05002421c9a2e18c1b5a67d6b0a919af4609389d6d79e2e0aa3472dda1321f8d5ff4b6c21cac878f98915fba13e8e5a153d8ec1634ab072bfb29bb3e3f3c9a980a84claims/registered/graph-concordance-matrix.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Ecological confounding: neighbourhood correlations reflect who lives where (poverty, age, race, migration), not the individual-level relation in the literature.","Common valence: nea…{ "id": "graph-concordance-matrix", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Across New York City's 42 UHF neighbourhoods, the sign of the correlation between two published indicators matches the majo…graph-concordance-matrix{"name":"prereg/graph-concordance-matrix","sha":"1a049aec1b4ba4c7df0f3c5bbe9dd9bd45f0a489"}0.6Claude (graph discovery study: concordance matrix){"commit":"14974809d38dfb08f5d04876755b33ef49c76dc1","committed_at":"2026-11-12T22:49:56-05:00"}——
graph-confounders-commute-obesityconfirmationAcross New York City's 42 UHF neighbourhoods, the association between the share of workers who walk or cycle to work and adult obesity becomes at least one third smaller when the adjustment set is the…2026-11-12T22:22:45-050060482012bb3dbee8c418ca0a05266238f5aa5f28db19695e68eb3271339456c67fb108703ede2ececf334868430dabe205a0c8cba93571c2c0ebb03f86a55384claims/registered/graph-confounders-commute-obesity.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"already_seen":"Seen before registration: data/derived/mobility/active_commute_obesity_uhf42.csv and active_commute_results.json (obesity, walk and bike shares, poverty and borough for all 42 UHFs; u…{ "id": "graph-confounders-commute-obesity", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Across New York City's 42 UHF neighbourhoods, the association between the share of workers who walk or cycle to wo…graph-confounders-commute-obesity{"name":"prereg/graph-confounders-commute-obesity","sha":"7b6d1f0cd8ec722dc6fe798f90321f5baeaf030f"}0.5Claude (graph confounders experiment), 12 November 2026{"commit":"713f50e3f0084165fb5cbcefaf1051d775910dbb","committed_at":"2026-11-12T22:22:52-05:00"}——
graph-confounders-surftemp-edconfirmationAcross New York City community districts, adding the share of older adults who live alone, the common cause that the System Public Graph's findings name for temperature and heat illness, to the analys…2026-11-12T23:43:38-0500d487c4638e9d364954b7e654a909b8af3f49793e70cc363a92855fcdb72fd298d6c7559d82e2219de30cb2e8ce75a48bbfc8abd2c6a0fd7d3d63dc12f5a884a8claims/registered/graph-confounders-surftemp-ed.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"already_seen":"Seen before registration by this registrant: data/derived/heat/bridge_cd.csv and bridge_nta.csv (every value of street-tree density, surface temperature, vegetative cover, heat ED rat…{ "id": "graph-confounders-surftemp-ed", "kind": "confirmation", "relates_to": "heat-surftemp-ed", "statement": "Across New York City community districts, adding the share of older adults who live…graph-confounders-surftemp-ed{"name":"prereg/graph-confounders-surftemp-ed","sha":"8c03da0ce072d178b04c8f83a0c8a64ac5af65f4"}0.5Claude (round 2, graph-derived adjustment sets for heat), 12 November 2026{"commit":"0bc45fab8220a0eb06012c4ca0385ceceaab16cc","committed_at":"2026-11-12T23:43:38-05:00"}——
graph-confounders-trees-surftempconfirmationAcross New York City community districts, the positive adjusted association between street-tree density and daytime surface temperature (+0.50 F per SD, the opposite of the research direction) becomes…2026-11-12T23:43:38-0500e7c71bc91bc4eae44eab1e33c2fea2f1d1f198f2e8d38b485a74d021ea9a66b47e74be08e3b4fb1c4e5582c6b01c122f8cc09b6b6c4d60bca0aa654bf4e3c3e2claims/registered/graph-confounders-trees-surftemp.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"already_seen":"Seen before registration by this registrant: data/derived/heat/bridge_cd.csv and bridge_nta.csv (every value of street-tree density, surface temperature, vegetative cover, heat ED rat…{ "id": "graph-confounders-trees-surftemp", "kind": "confirmation", "relates_to": "heat-trees-surftemp", "statement": "Across New York City community districts, the positive adjusted association b…graph-confounders-trees-surftemp{"name":"prereg/graph-confounders-trees-surftemp","sha":"48e0642f4d2f3b208445bc29be27cfc610d8c2f3"}0.4Claude (round 2, graph-derived adjustment sets for heat), 12 November 2026{"commit":"e0719f9b6f917f1dbcf2341b7790287aa8d56e21","committed_at":"2026-11-12T23:43:38-05:00"}——
graph-triad-cold-asthma-absencebridgeOn cold school days New York City public-school absence is higher than on other school days of the same week of the year, as the open triad temperature - asthma - school attendance in the System Publi…2026-11-12T22:51:37-0500e209073100a94c7f01555b38f651a628241c34d9cec205401a37b1f329a421837cc9c150788bb4281f459f3e384599b764658df818af5127dd5f0b9289b1a8dcclaims/registered/graph-triad-cold-asthma-absence.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"GHC…{"alternatives":["Temperature affects attendance directly (discomfort, travel, classrooms without air conditioning, families' choices), not through asthma; a ratio far above the composed interval indi…{ "id": "graph-triad-cold-asthma-absence", "kind": "bridge", "statement": "On cold school days New York City public-school absence is higher than on other school days of the same week of the year, …graph-triad-cold-asthma-absence{"name":"prereg/graph-triad-cold-asthma-absence","sha":"c6ab90335fd6d2fbaaad10cca44c749b4474c8ca"}0.55claude (graph triads study){"commit":"3c393f8db18e9c8ac2c613a24815ae4e360d65e9","committed_at":"2026-11-12T22:51:43-05:00"}——
graph-triad-hot-asthma-absencebridgeOn hot school days New York City public-school absence is higher than on other school days of the same week of the year, as the open triad temperature - asthma - school attendance in the System Public…2026-11-12T22:51:37-0500d47c0c36d36d614de5c5bdb0d943f9a98a09d59a3f467093d410e6276ceb3c0e88b3ae7fd467af9a76250d94c5386f38311a6a905a2849a7b910b75abbdfe9ccclaims/registered/graph-triad-hot-asthma-absence.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"GHC…{"alternatives":["Temperature affects attendance directly (discomfort, travel, classrooms without air conditioning, families' choices), not through asthma; a ratio far above the composed interval indi…{ "id": "graph-triad-hot-asthma-absence", "kind": "bridge", "statement": "On hot school days New York City public-school absence is higher than on other school days of the same week of the year, as…graph-triad-hot-asthma-absence{"name":"prereg/graph-triad-hot-asthma-absence","sha":"0c97c85342a559c605b39ae7cdb48327d3089530"}0.5claude (graph triads study){"commit":"86c42fc401e6682a570afeb801f9df9f74a10d41","committed_at":"2026-11-12T22:51:43-05:00"}——
heat-ac-heat-callsconfirmationThe rise of ambulance calls for heat illness with daily maximum temperature is steeper in the New York community districts where fewer households have air conditioning than in the districts where more…2026-11-13T07:52:12-0500e00e46b409098aff63a19afb68dd2de55c6d323b588a1ee34bee0c9de7886f0256a52a7e232f272882e3d482eaf7236daa8f48230094b9666cf8eb3b35d7d7b1claims/registered/heat-ac-heat-calls.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"GHC…{"already_seen":"The citywide daily series of heat-syndrome ED visits and its slope (4.09 per 5 C); the district rates of heat-stress ED visits over five years (heat-surftemp-ed), which are higher in …{ "id": "heat-ac-heat-calls", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "The rise of ambulance calls for heat illness with daily maximum temperature is steeper in the New York community districts where …heat-ac-heat-calls{"name":"prereg/heat-ac-heat-calls","sha":"ba1bbac8a62449ed1e1a55abbcf75c46c10c6881"}0.45Claude (heat solutions agent){"commit":"584e57e3a7c546b2c87aa670be25ecc539ee0e99","committed_at":"2026-11-13T08:05:56-05:00"}——
heat-ac-shootingsconfirmationThe rise of shootings with daily maximum temperature is steeper in the New York community districts where fewer households have air conditioning than in the districts where more have it.2026-11-13T07:52:12-0500567404dcc31818d12b262b40803c7974152ab3870c86eefc55255e2eb9f994a48e7252e1d19f47f09e559144c071bb9d6e0e00cae62ac1acebfb573a6031de25claims/registered/heat-ac-shootings.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"GHC…{"already_seen":"The citywide slope (1.146 per 5 C), its shape, its hours and the night-minimum results. design.py read the coordinates and jurisdiction code of shooting incidents without their dates …{ "id": "heat-ac-shootings", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "The rise of shootings with daily maximum temperature is steeper in the New York community districts where fewer households have ai…heat-ac-shootings{"name":"prereg/heat-ac-shootings","sha":"62a89452ae5c41daf677c03b1eaa3e48e069e6fb"}0.2Claude (heat solutions agent){"commit":"584e57e3a7c546b2c87aa670be25ecc539ee0e99","committed_at":"2026-11-13T08:05:56-05:00"}——
heat-ed-syndromicconfirmationIn New York City, daily emergency department visits for heat-related illness (DOHMH syndromic surveillance) rise steeply with the day's maximum temperature in the warm season.2026-11-12T15:19:38-05008d15c930565b1a7fe3f75990127c08ae83c4a6a92ed1f84624d75cc2413422ecb1f84798bce3147f9dd1bbff3aff672b51397d663088f09f107914b247911a98claims/registered/heat-ed-syndromic.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"GHC…{"alternatives":["Syndromic case definition changed in 2023 (applied back to all years, per DOHMH)","Chief-complaint keyword matching may respond to heat warnings and media attention, not only to illn…{ "id": "heat-ed-syndromic", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "In New York City, daily emergency department visits for heat-related illness (DOHMH syndromic surveillance) rise steeply with the …heat-ed-syndromic—0.95Claude (heat agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"176ef40c48e82c22f2984ca2d2abca18c056c9a0","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:19:38-05:00"}{"built_at":"2026-11-13T22:56:59-0500","checked_at":"2026-11-13T22:56:59-0500","decides":"prediction magnitude: IRR per 5 C between 1.5 and 5","deciding_number":"city_effect: IRR per 5 C of Central Pa…—
heat-extremes-downturnconfirmationIn US cities with many very hot days (Phoenix, Tucson, Dallas, Austin), police-recorded aggravated assaults are less frequent on days with a maximum temperature of 38 C or more than on days at 32 to 3…2026-11-13T07:58:34-0500d22d9dabfb9e58b688d59f50dc84e59e196ccd70ccc8a0a4826a42f20beadee627212a1907f271674c55af2f5e1dd5615a0e76b1e3b613de0b3ed27fb48b8926claims/registered/heat-extremes-downturn.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"d","class_meaning":"the outcome data were read for this claim before registration","classes":["d","a","b"],"early_sources":[{…{"already_seen":"Before registering I read, for each city, yearly totals and the overall mean daily count (printed by build.py) and the count of days by temperature. I saw seven Chicago daily counts f…{ "id": "heat-extremes-downturn", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "In US cities with many very hot days (Phoenix, Tucson, Dallas, Austin), police-recorded aggravated assaults are less frequent…heat-extremes-downturn{"name":"prereg/heat-extremes-downturn","sha":"96174c4f69c06edbe6b0d073867492a3ee81612e"}0.3Claude (agent, heat-extremes study, 13 Nov 2026){"commit":"479e77abb8faa17835f8f6201f39b0305b64220b","committed_at":"2026-11-13T08:15:25-05:00"}——
heat-inside-outsideconfirmationIn New York City from 2022, shootings outside rise with daily maximum temperature and shootings inside rise less: the inside rate ratio per 5 C is smaller than the outside one.2026-11-14T07:12:57-05009711212568454c182f3f799fc6add766886c624df4c5930fcecccbb589479ee66cd8ac56f5727d21dd4ad36f43c5878b60e57cd50f2a2cb3d5b9fe984302a340claims/registered/heat-inside-outside.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"already_seen":"Counts of incidents by year and location (2022: 242 inside, 1,474 outside victim rows; 2023: 218 and 1,032; 2024: 222 and 960), fetched on 14 November 2026 to check that the field is …{ "id": "heat-inside-outside", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "In New York City from 2022, shootings outside rise with daily maximum temperature and shootings inside rise less: the inside rat…heat-inside-outside—0.55Claude (coordinator), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"44d469d93c08e265bce52a167febe0ac5e8e6c0f","committed_at":"2026-11-14T07:12:57-05:00"}——
heat-inside-outside-2006confirmationIn New York City from 2006, shootings outside rise with daily maximum temperature and shootings inside rise less: the inside rate ratio per 5 C is smaller than the outside one.2026-11-14T07:13:15-05007e134210eb08209ce565179c2abf900b4e684107d781be050c58d161906198fd24e33acd95fd2b1a2058060f128abdddbbaaa7353717574fcea264141acb01bfclaims/registered/heat-inside-outside-2006.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"already_seen":"Counts of inside incidents by year for 2006 to 2017 (155 to 265 a year) and the 2022 to 2024 counts named in heat-inside-outside, seen on 14 November 2026 while checking the field. No…{ "id": "heat-inside-outside-2006", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "In New York City from 2006, shootings outside rise with daily maximum temperature and shootings inside rise less: the insid…heat-inside-outside-2006—0.6Claude (coordinator), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"cfd2556b88b1f7b5b594b4f80caf040f1752c526","committed_at":"2026-11-14T07:13:15-05:00"}——
heat-mech-intoxbridgeAlcohol and drug intoxication is not a measurable step between heat and shootings in New York City: daily FDNY EMS dispatches for drug and alcohol abuse rise with the day's maximum temperature by only…2026-11-12T22:21:55-0500c3a02fb57ef61909330e922821425cff6e396b1bd7a467f0caaec172bc364a8f04cf5c8d2af31160bee7f98acb49a73c60d8ca4599c4d01b73e4944803110919claims/registered/heat-mech-intox.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"c","class_meaning":"a shared cache: the query was fetched for an earlier claim and holds this claim's outcome","classes":["c"…{"alternatives":["EMS dispatches measure intoxication severe enough for an ambulance, not drinking among people who shoot or are shot; a small A may reflect a poor proxy and does not show that alcohol…{ "id": "heat-mech-intox", "kind": "bridge", "statement": "Alcohol and drug intoxication is not a measurable step between heat and shootings in New York City: daily FDNY EMS dispatches for drug and…heat-mech-intox{"name":"prereg/heat-mech-intox","sha":"f7ec41f6e0a3691fac936f864f1d86a20db24628"}0.75Claude (graph-mechanisms agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"cddeb94a06ae9e91a49ab58c3b9b8b1a63774850","committed_at":"2026-11-12T22:21:55-05:00"}——
heat-mech-outdoorsbridgePeople outdoors is a step between heat and shootings in New York City: daily 311 Noise - Street/Sidewalk complaints, a proxy for street activity, rise with the day's maximum temperature, and adding th…2026-11-12T22:21:54-0500bb31218120e2f55dc75988f9f98a2503dff74e49902b3790984da2859b0e409d924912c5bf257c5674b83d0137de364b86db671f600cc9a85b3dde64282cb8d7claims/registered/heat-mech-outdoors.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"c","class_meaning":"a shared cache: the query was fetched for an earlier claim and holds this claim's outcome","classes":["c"…{"alternatives":["Noise complaints rise in heat because windows are open and complainants are at home, not because more people are on the street; the proxy then overstates the first link.","Complaints…{ "id": "heat-mech-outdoors", "kind": "bridge", "statement": "People outdoors is a step between heat and shootings in New York City: daily 311 Noise - Street/Sidewalk complaints, a proxy for street…heat-mech-outdoors{"name":"prereg/heat-mech-outdoors","sha":"7a5eca19412164609f1330416e434e00fe3b6a80"}0.3Claude (graph-mechanisms agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"1c2563694ee25ba8fb8948300283e9e7b90ed346","committed_at":"2026-11-12T22:21:54-05:00"}——
heat-night-minimumconfirmationOn days with a maximum of 27 C or more, shootings in New York rise with the preceding night's minimum temperature at a fixed daily maximum, and the rise in shootings from 27 to 33 C falls in the hours…2026-11-13T01:24:29-0500e07dcc3e1431af8e1b1fd759821e53a861cf1349456f11dd64e37523fc5bde54b4ca368bbd490ac307447ec6af16bc6dc23a3124af56d49571dd32c2d63fc47fclaims/registered/heat-night-minimum.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"GHC…{"already_seen":"TMAX-only models of shootings are seen in both cities (linear, 4-df spline, piecewise-linear; New York 33 against 27 C 1.122, 1.048 to 1.202; Chicago 1.058, 1.014 to 1.105). Two earli…{ "id": "heat-night-minimum", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "On days with a maximum of 27 C or more, shootings in New York rise with the preceding night's minimum temperature at a fixed dail…heat-night-minimum{"name":"prereg/heat-night-minimum","sha":"44edbc9fc54dea8523c36ae75638c94d63b79889"}0.25Claude (round 5 agent, night minimum){"commit":"49a9380ea1f8039cd9d9e35c20c3bcdb8de4d38c","committed_at":"2026-11-13T01:24:29-05:00"}——
heat-school-outconfirmationOn weekdays within six weeks of the last and first day of classes in New York public schools, shootings are more frequent on days out of school than on school days at the same temperature.2026-11-13T07:52:12-05002bafdf8baa8b39a7a06fdcc2c2383295f76c760317887c6cfe7a087c87dac831c5b774015d46983f1168e634601f1e8e7385a5ebac39882f4851636f27bb0418claims/registered/heat-school-out.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"GHC…{"already_seen":"The citywide daily series of shootings and its temperature models; the hourly distribution by temperature band. I have not tabulated shootings by date relative to the school calendar,…{ "id": "heat-school-out", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "On weekdays within six weeks of the last and first day of classes in New York public schools, shootings are more frequent on days ou…heat-school-out{"name":"prereg/heat-school-out","sha":"481093e1cbfe47f6b1c06d0b0eb3477612d8c973"}0.12Claude (heat solutions agent){"commit":"584e57e3a7c546b2c87aa670be25ecc539ee0e99","committed_at":"2026-11-13T08:05:56-05:00"}——
heat-shootingsconfirmationIn New York City, the daily number of shooting incidents rises with the day's maximum temperature at Central Park, within month and year, by about 5 to 20 percent per 5 C.2026-11-12T15:19:38-0500b2a1bd8ecec550da1e1e07d368d2e5f1b7d108b07ce6f51ef658bbb197ebb762f3c9ef53efa7dc3d9904edcb9d6d17f300dabf7194a6629cf3bc037b8bebac52claims/registered/heat-shootings.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"GHC…{"alternatives":["Residual seasonality within month (school calendar, summer youth programmes, daylight) correlated with temperature","Time outdoors and street encounters as the mechanism (the tempera…{ "id": "heat-shootings", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "In New York City, the daily number of shooting incidents rises with the day's maximum temperature at Central Park, within month and y…heat-shootings—0.9Claude (heat agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"67507946fe78b52a39097d7882340ebe335aadad","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:19:38-05:00"}{"built_at":"2026-11-13T22:56:48-0500","checked_at":"2026-11-13T22:56:48-0500","decides":"support_if: lower 95% limit above 1.00","deciding_number":"city_effect: IRR per 5 C of Central Park TMAX (lag …—
heat-surftemp-edbridgeAcross New York City community districts, hotter daytime surface temperature goes with a higher rate of heat-stress emergency department visits, and this survives adjustment for poverty, percent Black…2026-11-12T15:19:38-05005a038bcc91f7674e377aa29597cffa388b4f5b516779b75b86967174cc56fbd780b9faef3da227acd52387f7f1a34dd6b0af480a3da2a86aed7c899c3cd15030claims/registered/heat-surftemp-ed.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Poverty and race drive both residence in hot, treeless districts and ED use (insurance, ED as usual source of care, outdoor work)","Residents are exposed where they work and travel, …{ "id": "heat-surftemp-ed", "kind": "bridge", "statement": "Across New York City community districts, hotter daytime surface temperature goes with a higher rate of heat-stress emergency department …heat-surftemp-ed—0.35Claude (heat agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"a3433edb9816901d4dfef88c598c4968e27d2aef","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:19:38-05:00"}——
heat-trees-airtemp-hyperlocalbridgeWithin the same neighbourhood and day, NYC hyperlocal sensors with more street trees nearby record lower afternoon air temperature.2026-11-12T15:19:38-050053c70b072b99ff4598066a241a1e0f9f5d418e24f58a1eff529a14286e473d94b911e287eab4911bbef842e15b3a82612474bbe2b41bf9a5c198637b8cadb9daclaims/registered/heat-trees-airtemp-hyperlocal.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Sensor siting: sensors on light poles vs trees differ in shade and height (install_type is controlled)","Trees cluster on residential side streets, away from wide arterial roads and …{ "id": "heat-trees-airtemp-hyperlocal", "kind": "bridge", "statement": "Within the same neighbourhood and day, NYC hyperlocal sensors with more street trees nearby record lower afternoon air tempe…heat-trees-airtemp-hyperlocal—0.55Claude (heat agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"aba78e7dbcb7360873c7bcee0315a8139ab846d4","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:19:38-05:00"}——
heat-trees-canopy-within-ntaconfirmationWithin the same neighbourhood (NTA) and day, NYC hyperlocal temperature sensors with a larger share of vegetation within 50 m, measured from the 2022 NAIP near-infrared aerial flight, record lower aft…2026-11-12T20:17:43-0500d917a9c71cdd59cea7ee87c312caf112307ca8b75f6d935ebfed166de124f5585a51f1d3c54d67929109d754bfd9a7b392d73dc01169cdedf7789a75ee138f6fclaims/registered/heat-trees-canopy-within-nta.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"c","class_meaning":"a shared cache: the query was fetched for an earlier claim and holds this claim's outcome","classes":["c"…{"already_seen":"The project has already tested these sensors. Claim heat-trees-airtemp-hyperlocal (registered and decided 12 Nov 2026) regressed the same afternoon temperatures on the count of live s…{ "id": "heat-trees-canopy-within-nta", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Within the same neighbourhood (NTA) and day, NYC hyperlocal temperature sensors with a larger share of vegetation withi…heat-trees-canopy-within-nta{"name":"prereg/heat-trees-canopy-within-nta","sha":"8615b09a1334386e88807f69a3463d722d46129c"}0.3Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"92a79da550aadacfa771f0dee34ec9d4b3250057","committed_at":"2026-11-12T20:17:43-05:00"}——
heat-trees-ed-chainbridgeStreet trees lower heat-stress emergency department visits in New York City through lower neighbourhood temperature: the composed path trees -> surface temperature -> heat ED rate is negative across c…2026-11-12T15:19:38-05009d0cb8b0e5b62f276a3d37134db4773e9c31fba59119b4f6855176493f745ec3eb85300472b3c8d1c629263a1c0cfb19dc332b03b138ca55bdb1190f762c3bf0claims/registered/heat-trees-ed-chain.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Income and race drive tree cover (historic planting and redlining), surface temperature and ED use together; 59 areal units cannot separate them","Ecological fallacy: area associatio…{ "id": "heat-trees-ed-chain", "kind": "bridge", "statement": "Street trees lower heat-stress emergency department visits in New York City through lower neighbourhood temperature: the composed path…heat-trees-ed-chain—0.35Claude (heat agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"4156c2540e73a13972b8bf228a9a55e48513349a","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:19:38-05:00"}——
heat-trees-surftempbridgeAcross New York City community districts, more street trees per square kilometre go with a lower daytime summer surface temperature, after adjusting for poverty and percent Black residents.2026-11-12T15:19:38-0500a1001b709d21ebc86de614001fd350d9115b0fff15a0aaeea827d07def3cf453c440ba31be1db74f59827d0c7701941ad20a4457039bdbfbca91a64958e32663claims/registered/heat-trees-surftemp.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Building density and impervious cover drive both fewer street trees and hotter surfaces (dense Manhattan cores vs low-rise Staten Island)","Distance to water and parkland (parks are …{ "id": "heat-trees-surftemp", "kind": "bridge", "statement": "Across New York City community districts, more street trees per square kilometre go with a lower daytime summer surface temperature, a…heat-trees-surftemp—0.65Claude (heat agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"b7ba99f54fe25369ad1efe5db87bba0434642381","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:19:38-05:00"}——
levers-vacant-lot-trial-matchbridgeOf New York's tax lots recorded as vacant land (MapPLUTO 26v2 land use 11) in the census tracts with the most shootings, about three in ten resemble the lots of the Philadelphia vacant-lot trial (smal…2026-11-13T13:31:12-050031d31f4114ae025178cede169e4da36d9648c5c5dd6438c6eab15c73b7ee90f65aafb8f512f9012d3d0b51f6d160a7cc33e6fe795e20e2fc79053022487e0feaclaims/registered/levers-vacant-lot-trial-match.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Lots recorded as vacant are held for development and show DOB activity, so few resemble the trial's abandoned lots.","Small vacant lots in high-shooting tracts are paved for parking …{ "id": "levers-vacant-lot-trial-match", "kind": "bridge", "statement": "Of New York's tax lots recorded as vacant land (MapPLUTO 26v2 land use 11) in the census tracts with the most shootings, abo…levers-vacant-lot-trial-match{"name":"prereg/levers-vacant-lot-trial-match","sha":"2a7c4b4f2124654b88ba6d236bdd5c40191f0bcb"}0.45claude (levers agent, 13 November 2026){"commit":"2a7c4b4f2124654b88ba6d236bdd5c40191f0bcb","committed_at":"2026-11-13T13:31:12-05:00"}{"built_at":"2026-11-13T22:56:54-0500","checked_at":"2026-11-13T22:56:54-0500","decides":"support_if: share in 0.18-0.45 and number in 400-1,500","deciding_number":"trial-like share of land use 11 lot…—
mob-active-commute-obesityconfirmationAcross New York City's UHF42 neighbourhoods, a higher share of workers who walk or cycle to work goes with a lower share of adults with obesity, after adjusting for neighbourhood poverty.2026-11-12T15:25:31-0500ae99f6c6638ffddcd7df7f9576b3f372e9359d98dd86b546a4c396e9a1ba80ae6951d38110f1fb40623681207f01a9e31c612b199daad1e1c9f14cbefe5671fdclaims/registered/mob-active-commute-obesity.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Income, education and race/ethnicity composition (poverty is the named confounder; others are not measured here)","Density and Manhattan: walking to work is common where jobs are clo…{ "id": "mob-active-commute-obesity", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Across New York City's UHF42 neighbourhoods, a higher share of workers who walk or cycle to work goes with a lower share …mob-active-commute-obesity—0.5mobility agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon{"commit":"f99a06e7f3fcda921080138c6d51ab92789e947e","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:25:31-05:00"}——
mob-asthma-pollutionconfirmationAcross New York City's 42 UHF neighbourhoods, asthma emergency department visit rates are higher where NYCCAS annual average NO2 and PM2.5 are higher, and the association survives adjustment for neigh…2026-11-12T15:15:19-050011508650c9dadd315538f4c32b54a08e2ad8e0c053579c565a071f8e45e4d7dc73f18ad7f798b2039cc9f149b99d74c7a7a142a8181de8e3a875d13b1e1d4fd0claims/registered/mob-asthma-pollution.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Poverty and the conditions that travel with it (housing quality, pests, mould, smoking, access to primary care)","Ecological fallacy: residence of ED patients vs where exposure occur…{ "id": "mob-asthma-pollution", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Across New York City's 42 UHF neighbourhoods, asthma emergency department visit rates are higher where NYCCAS annual average NO…mob-asthma-pollution—0.35mobility agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon{"commit":"f2d4f724d505e61fea1b78c9d80bdc50799e5722","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:15:27-05:00"}——
mob-crz-airconfirmationAfter congestion pricing began on 5 January 2025, daily NO2 and PM2.5 at EPA regulatory monitors inside the Congestion Relief Zone fell relative to monitors elsewhere in New York City.2026-11-12T15:15:19-050006a52e5821eaef00d9a98ec30141044967099a55e5bf9ea73d203bc02cdbcfa988cc69ffcaf32ebabb9eef762f8d190bf81004ee6dc1a184f151354ad2510c7fclaims/registered/mob-crz-air.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Regional background change (wildfire smoke in 2023, transported sulfate) — absorbed by date effects only if it is spatially uniform","Local construction or site-specific changes near…{ "id": "mob-crz-air", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "After congestion pricing began on 5 January 2025, daily NO2 and PM2.5 at EPA regulatory monitors inside the Congestion Relief Zone fell …mob-crz-air—0.35mobility agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon{"commit":"f2d4f724d505e61fea1b78c9d80bdc50799e5722","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:15:27-05:00"}——
mob-crz-air-nyccasconfirmationNYCCAS annual average NO2 in the five UHF42 neighbourhoods south of 60th Street fell from 2024 to 2025, after congestion pricing began, more than in neighbourhoods outside Manhattan.2026-11-12T15:24:55-050012a668a997839133b62c44c15db11750f0546e875f070963223d5b55759f39f54badba8c1513e9f7de56dad945eec708765e0f5ec3071ccc28d779bc0fb8459aclaims/registered/mob-crz-air-nyccas.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Regional background change (wildfire smoke in 2023, transported sulfate) — absorbed by date effects only if it is spatially uniform","Local construction or site-specific changes near…{ "id": "mob-crz-air-nyccas", "supersedes": "mob-crz-air", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "NYCCAS annual average NO2 in the five UHF42 neighbourhoods south of 60th Street fell from 2024 to 2…mob-crz-air-nyccas—0.3mobility agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon{"commit":"2199e6a9a2f1ffb45a2c8435531972fb5febed69","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:24:55-05:00"}—mob-crz-air
mob-crz-trafficconfirmationCongestion pricing in Manhattan's Central Business District (from 5 January 2025) raised taxi and for-hire vehicle speeds and reduced TLC trip counts in the CBD relative to the rest of New York City.2026-11-12T15:15:19-05007e080860acc4dff2c0ecba9b77628be759c0f9681c9daa5a3e815eabdb578b2655d6aa820704cde2718a46c8fbbcc99f72762af67fdf676ec71d58a913c5dceaclaims/registered/mob-crz-traffic.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Post-pandemic return-to-office trend that differs between the CBD and outer boroughs","Seasonal and weather shocks (absorbed in part by calendar-month terms; common shocks by the com…{ "id": "mob-crz-traffic", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Congestion pricing in Manhattan's Central Business District (from 5 January 2025) raised taxi and for-hire vehicle speeds and reduce…mob-crz-traffic—0.8mobility agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon{"commit":"f2d4f724d505e61fea1b78c9d80bdc50799e5722","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:15:27-05:00"}{"built_at":"2026-11-13T22:57:06-0500","checked_at":"2026-11-13T22:57:06-0500","decides":"prediction magnitude: speed +5% to +15% and trips -3% to -12%","deciding_number":"city_effect: percent change …—
mob-speedcam-247confirmationExtending New York City's school-zone speed cameras to 24-hour, 7-day operation on 1 August 2022 reduced injury crashes in the newly enforced hours (weekday 10 pm-6 am and weekends) relative to the we…2026-11-12T15:15:19-0500dceaaebfd4c399d50f80cf40c4ef0435101593ff9e9723f0a57f810a9c422043033fdd7cd638a2d19d63dbb0694c2b51ee32e9bf99bef497605570576d9fff7eclaims/registered/mob-speedcam-247.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Differential post-pandemic recovery of night and weekend traffic (nightlife) relative to weekday daytime","Changes in NYPD crash reporting or in the share of crashes with location an…{ "id": "mob-speedcam-247", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Extending New York City's school-zone speed cameras to 24-hour, 7-day operation on 1 August 2022 reduced injury crashes in the newl…mob-speedcam-247—0.3mobility agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon{"commit":"f2d4f724d505e61fea1b78c9d80bdc50799e5722","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:15:27-05:00"}——
moon-full-emergenciesconfirmationOn the day of a full moon and the days either side of it, New York City has no more and no fewer shootings, ambulance incidents or injury crashes than on other days, within stated equivalence bounds.2026-11-14T07:10:45-0500e9097b4a39e764212a31c6646953e0cf2d31fdeae07451bebe7dea84a2c598bbe0f412aa673e9062eb51427a2dcfc710f1c9e07a3c838308c4dcb26ba631ed0bclaims/registered/moon-full-emergencies.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"already_seen":"The three daily series were built for earlier claims. None has been tabulated or plotted against lunar phase by this registrant. The equivalence bounds were set from expected standard…{ "id": "moon-full-emergencies", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "On the day of a full moon and the days either side of it, New York City has no more and no fewer shootings, ambulance incident…moon-full-emergencies—0.6Claude (coordinator), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"f673f98dcd0cf1d6150dcf1e58be357dd3a2d6b0","committed_at":"2026-11-14T07:10:45-05:00"}——
nbhd-noise311-exposureconflict311 noise complaint rates by census tract are a poor measure of noise exposure: they align weakly with modelled transportation noise and more strongly with neighbourhood change (rent increase and grow…2026-11-12T15:24:16-0500723e5cfcd9ef6a3b82a2fe81579fee25d9595c76bcb788b31f1eb7502bb723fd7ce4d20ddbd83685d9992d9813877419677d1c0b395320b4816b4c3de4bd735cclaims/registered/nbhd-noise311-exposure.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Residential complaints concern neighbour noise, which the transport noise map does not model; a weak link to modelled noise is then expected even if complaints measure exposure to th…{ "id": "nbhd-noise311-exposure", "kind": "conflict", "statement": "311 noise complaint rates by census tract are a poor measure of noise exposure: they align weakly with modelled transportation no…nbhd-noise311-exposure—0.45claude-code agent (neighbourhood), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"27eb5a3e5ec0526889ed3d250ee3a81a9a7437a2","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:24:16-05:00"}——
nbhd-rodents-asthmaconfirmationAcross NYC's 42 UHF neighbourhoods, a higher share of homes with mice or rats in the building is associated with higher asthma emergency department visit rates in children aged 5-17, and the associati…2026-11-12T15:24:16-05007e57999e5f83174070afcbefbef53ab051e737915fca1c8897d763d3dd28c33c33b390358a9fac4f4051861044c7402075cde6f9d1d396bd83384dbcbf5b68f5claims/registered/nbhd-rodents-asthma.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Poverty, housing quality, cockroach allergen, smoking and outdoor air pollution all vary with rodent infestation across neighbourhoods.","The research concerns indoor mouse allergen …{ "id": "nbhd-rodents-asthma", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Across NYC's 42 UHF neighbourhoods, a higher share of homes with mice or rats in the building is associated with higher asthma e…nbhd-rodents-asthma—0.3claude-code agent (neighbourhood), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"a8170c66d221df8f897a65e02d8bad45612839c3","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:24:16-05:00"}——
nbhd-vacant-shootingsconfirmationAcross New York City census tracts, a larger share of lot area in vacant land (MapPLUTO land use 11) is associated with more NYPD-recorded shootings per resident, after adjustment for poverty, populat…2026-11-12T15:24:16-0500a65620b20ad5d385bf13bbcffcf3f26465e2fd39695e022376bfc2031db70a8019cca43b45a21e0abfc2447b7758f99f9f5fea3272bac2f199cc5b9db2c2d4ffclaims/registered/nbhd-vacant-shootings.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Poverty and disinvestment cause both vacancy and violence (confounding); adjustment is coarse.","NYC vacant lots are often staged for construction in rising-rent areas, which have fa…{ "id": "nbhd-vacant-shootings", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Across New York City census tracts, a larger share of lot area in vacant land (MapPLUTO land use 11) is associated with more N…nbhd-vacant-shootings—0.4claude-code agent (neighbourhood), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"f0e950edd596d625482ebc768014732b2e7abe4a","committed_at":"2026-11-12T15:24:16-05:00"}——
repro-dcp-2025-completionsreproductionThe DCP Housing Production Snapshot's count of 38,682 housing units completed in new buildings in 2025 is reproduced, within 4% (allowing for revision between the 25Q4 and 26Q2.1 releases), by summing…2026-11-12T19:56:34-05002bbc079a78bf19f98dc822453ac50780f634050ebab6de515556b7b32e01cd70e439451e20895b56af44ec27460cfa0a84698e621fb8ebd9b4b15c7f1df58a9eclaims/registered/repro-dcp-2025-completions.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Release revision: the 26q2.1 copy differs from 25Q4 by late-recorded COs and DCP edits, so a mismatch may be revision and not a different rule.","The snapshot counts units incrementa…{ "id": "repro-dcp-2025-completions", "kind": "reproduction", "target": { "report": "NYC Housing Production Snapshot 2025", "agency": "NYC Department of City Planning (DCP)", "date": "ArcGIS …repro-dcp-2025-completions{"name":"prereg/repro-dcp-2025-completions","sha":"bc791bcac410b0b42983aa69584e6d4232821042"}0.6reproduction agent (Claude Opus 5.5), session fe2cedf2{"commit":"308dd84da88cee332720367ce8f4b723538c1320","committed_at":"2026-11-12T19:56:37-05:00"}——
repro-dot-2025-deathsreproductionThe NYPD open collision tables, queried in November 2026, reproduce DOT's 2 January 2026 figures for 2025 traffic deaths (205), 2024 deaths (253), pedestrian deaths (111, 122), deaths by borough and i…2026-11-12T19:56:43-0500830c41a9b091a8f6b1582f61c3c6e47acce8f519bb95594f03ffdaa534af28acf7f97dfb467ab9476ea695fd929af3ae0e297973150e7c6b121ec338381f9161claims/registered/repro-dot-2025-deaths.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["DOT's reconciled file adds deaths that occur after the crash report (NYPD records the injury at the scene; the person later dies) and so exceeds the NYPD counts.","DOT's definition e…{ "id": "repro-dot-2025-deaths", "kind": "reproduction", "target": { "report": "Traffic deaths reach all-time low (press release)", "agency": "New York City Department of Transportation", "da…repro-dot-2025-deaths{"name":"prereg/repro-dot-2025-deaths","sha":"95b89272d0b83d2c3cb2515d787496f0c2300954"}0.3claude (reproduction agent, Claude Code, 12 Nov 2026){"commit":"f2fd68b316a8534de082cc873a3e4eb912be4806","committed_at":"2026-11-12T19:56:45-05:00"}——
repro-mmr-cbd-speedreproductionThe MMR Fiscal 2026 values of average yellow-taxi travel speed in the Manhattan CBD (6.9 mph in FY25 and 6.5 mph in FY26) can be recomputed from TLC yellow taxi trip records within 0.2 mph under the p…2026-11-12T19:56:25-0500a328718a0a0626bbf09fe1fcfbcb948f6ca0fb7030ecf9f312f8bb4677b79933effd9525987d5ae6252c362628d84ca719507bf32a2c59d59e4b9ff677e29550claims/registered/repro-mmr-cbd-speed.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"b","class_meaning":"a design, power or calibration read, pre-period data, or metadata","classes":["b"],"early_sources":[{"cla…{"alternatives":["DOT uses GPS traces or a probe-vehicle feed (not trip records), so trip-record speeds differ in level","DOT uses a different zone set or a different time rule (trip wholly within 8AM…{ "id": "repro-mmr-cbd-speed", "kind": "reproduction", "target": { "report": "Mayor's Management Report, Fiscal 2026, Department of Transportation chapter", "agency": "NYC Mayor's Office of Ope…repro-mmr-cbd-speed{"name":"prereg/repro-mmr-cbd-speed","sha":"016ac7a0559035823965f7243ebe8114e4eeab1e"}0.35reproduction agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon{"commit":"928573e47944ef8cc17ce9463528a2a3f542c029","committed_at":"2026-11-12T19:56:25-05:00"}——
restaurants-nta-harshnessconfirmationCritical violations detected per routine initial inspection are not even across Manhattan's 2020 NTAs: after cuisine, chain status, quarter, day of week, daily inspection workload, new-restaurant stat…2026-11-13T14:18:37-05006f6e2eac57f3253c217e8cf0115e3b40ee9999caf31641c9e2e48a3ecaa53bc7f4f49ad439361d489415c0d23533a8104f91803418d3744de4bb19e27ea935e5claims/registered/restaurants-nta-harshness.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Inspector assignment: inspectors work in geographic teams, so an NTA's rate reflects its inspectors' stringency rather than its restaurants.","Unmeasured restaurant mix: size, menu c…{ "id": "restaurants-nta-harshness", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Critical violations detected per routine initial inspection are not even across Manhattan's 2020 NTAs: after cuisine, chai…restaurants-nta-harshness{"name":"prereg/restaurants-nta-harshness","sha":"55dabf10dd2516710e6509521f4cfef641e0039f"}0.55claude (restaurants agent, 13 November 2026){"commit":"55dabf10dd2516710e6509521f4cfef641e0039f","committed_at":"2026-11-13T14:18:37-05:00"}{"built_at":"2026-11-13T23:35:50-0500","checked_at":"2026-11-13T23:36:06-0500","decides":"support_if: permutation p <= 0.01 and tau >= 0.05; refute_if: permutation p > 0.10","deciding_number":"city_ef…—
restaurants-score-complaintsconfirmationRestaurants that score 14 or more points (not A-range) at a routine initial inspection draw more 311 Food Poisoning complaints in the following 365 days than restaurants that score 0-13, after borough…2026-11-13T14:12:00-05006e8e2be9eb4e8187941bcac75955c9add2f3fcc1ff77822bd68ee8cf7261025433eaa939f6d7238359f2b56ff6c2dbc0929d07bf23f201b4dc8befccc0715452claims/registered/restaurants-score-complaints.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"43n…{"alternatives":["Volume: busy restaurants have more diners, so more complaints, and more chances for violations; the noise placebo and cuisine and chain controls address part of this.","Reporting pro…{ "id": "restaurants-score-complaints", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Restaurants that score 14 or more points (not A-range) at a routine initial inspection draw more 311 Food Poisoning com…restaurants-score-complaints{"name":"prereg/restaurants-score-complaints","sha":"a70335a4283e34f0e80c3048f3bcdee40cf7e81e"}0.3claude (restaurants agent, 13 November 2026){"commit":"a70335a4283e34f0e80c3048f3bcdee40cf7e81e","committed_at":"2026-11-13T14:12:00-05:00"}——
retimed-daytime-burglaryconfirmationResidential burglaries that began between 08:00 and 18:00 fell on Mondays and Fridays relative to Tuesday to Thursday between 2015-2019 and 2023-2026, by between half and all of the proportional fall …2026-11-12T23:48:46-05001d701f85abd57987c8ed0c01399a6b1883f353bb7d5c0918046546108f38b9a8ecf173a9a623118e615004d1c607fbebe521a37f0a867facc70ea90db380b999claims/registered/retimed-daytime-burglary.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"already_seen":"Earlier claims queried NYPD complaints for seven felony offences by month, hour and premises (further-subway-crime claims) and for shootings by day; none tabulated burglary by weekday…{ "id": "retimed-daytime-burglary", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Residential burglaries that began between 08:00 and 18:00 fell on Mondays and Fridays relative to Tuesday to Thursday betwe…retimed-daytime-burglary{"name":"prereg/retimed-daytime-burglary","sha":"13e72d3c7ba9c6472d4503ccc500cb75fc57c500"}0.25Claude (round 2, re-timed consequences agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"52f3c02e08750c8aeea17b9fd5b4350a2afad816","committed_at":"2026-11-12T23:48:55-05:00"}——
retimed-ems-presenceconfirmationDaytime EMS incidents in the Manhattan business district (community districts 101 to 106) fell on Mondays and Fridays relative to Tuesday to Thursday between 2018-2019 and October 2024-September 2026,…2026-11-12T23:48:46-0500ba0e599732842d1b203cbc648dd0acb0cddf7b85b93e6c06b12cebca86e98f644296f9e792f4d61034b3480c2155acae1fa813c559cccc15a33e5601759d4064claims/registered/retimed-ems-presence.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"b","class_meaning":"a design, power or calibration read, pre-period data, or metadata","classes":["b"],"early_sources":[{"cla…{"already_seen":"Earlier claims queried EMS incidents by day for shootings and stabbings, drug and psychiatric calls, and asthma, citywide; none tabulated incidents by community district or by weekday…{ "id": "retimed-ems-presence", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Daytime EMS incidents in the Manhattan business district (community districts 101 to 106) fell on Mondays and Fridays relative …retimed-ems-presence{"name":"prereg/retimed-ems-presence","sha":"2c0e8b27937f0746a39dd5e29c004b063c9d5470"}0.45Claude (round 2, re-timed consequences agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"5c3e76319b141b8275a2d5e4fac5f64df217eab5","committed_at":"2026-11-12T23:48:55-05:00"}——
retimed-taxi-fhv-pickupsconfirmationBetween February-March 2019 and February-March 2026, daytime taxi and high-volume for-hire pickups on Mondays and Fridays fell relative to Tuesday-to-Thursday pickups in the taxi zones whose subway en…2026-11-12T23:48:46-0500a4208ae183234df3c7030abc703801785f69d18c46bc96534778383bc670e6b7904ebe298c9f11d9a11dacc86d7ee6430cbd09007e899bbe1ee6fc44786e65aaclaims/registered/retimed-taxi-fhv-pickups.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"b","class_meaning":"a design, power or calibration read, pre-period data, or metadata","classes":["b"],"early_sources":[{"cla…{"already_seen":"The project holds TLC pickups by zone and day for January-March 2018 and 2019 (transit-fhv-price-subway, used for totals near subway complexes, not by weekday), June-October 2023 and …{ "id": "retimed-taxi-fhv-pickups", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Between February-March 2019 and February-March 2026, daytime taxi and high-volume for-hire pickups on Mondays and Fridays f…retimed-taxi-fhv-pickups{"name":"prereg/retimed-taxi-fhv-pickups","sha":"e6bf43b2d9b07b28713da586eb27ae541aa1dfe8"}0.5Claude (round 2, re-timed consequences agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"e0b4eecd70952329bfd68a44e5e44f96018c0d5e","committed_at":"2026-11-12T23:48:54-05:00"}——
rlc-expansion-injuriesconfirmationAt the intersections where New York City switched on red-light cameras in January-August 2026, persons injured or killed in crashes fell relative to matched signalized intersections.2026-11-13T12:39:17-05005320da2f1ed2aa89793fc6ce1555fd7c1b16e49d5d752142b38173eaebb41f9462b136d2183b84b950a7e4819f6fb00dde1d9af49f7acfbf5d80df6e9cfd74f1claims/registered/rlc-expansion-injuries.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Regression to the mean: new camera sites were chosen for high crash or violation counts; matching on pre-period crash counts and the two-year pre window reduce, but do not remove, th…{ "id": "rlc-expansion-injuries", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "At the intersections where New York City switched on red-light cameras in January-August 2026, persons injured or killed in c…rlc-expansion-injuries{"name":"prereg/rlc-expansion-injuries","sha":"3e747066e417950621ada4cb0610650dbb5e77b4"}0.3street-safety agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon{"commit":"3e747066e417950621ada4cb0610650dbb5e77b4","committed_at":"2026-11-13T12:39:17-05:00"}——
rlc-expansion-rearendconflictAt the intersections where New York City switched on red-light cameras in January-August 2026, rear-end crashes rose relative to matched signalized intersections, as the meta-analyses predict and cont…2026-11-13T12:39:17-0500a0d11a850d2da5029a3ae583a3ce37a4ff36a4b4846df639fa569276879ace9e43b4b3b99083d4aad69e16798e120c427c8175bfb5f5ca7bafeb389c1ffca73fclaims/registered/rlc-expansion-rearend.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Regression to the mean: new camera sites were chosen for high crash or violation counts; matching on pre-period crash counts and the two-year pre window reduce, but do not remove, th…{ "id": "rlc-expansion-rearend", "kind": "conflict", "statement": "At the intersections where New York City switched on red-light cameras in January-August 2026, rear-end crashes rose relative to m…rlc-expansion-rearend{"name":"prereg/rlc-expansion-rearend","sha":"3e747066e417950621ada4cb0610650dbb5e77b4"}0.3street-safety agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon{"commit":"3e747066e417950621ada4cb0610650dbb5e77b4","committed_at":"2026-11-13T12:39:17-05:00"}{"built_at":"2026-11-13T23:36:06-0500","checked_at":"2026-11-13T23:36:10-0500","decides":"support_if: 95% interval above 1.00 and rule 8 D >= 4 against 1.33","deciding_number":"city_effect: ratio of r…—
sim-crz-holdout-2026confirmationThe two links of the congestion-pricing simulator that are fitted to city data on non-holiday weekdays of 6 January to 23 December 2025 predict days of 5 January to 30 June 2026 that were not used to …2026-11-13T08:05:49-0500ffa4b6e47f0bdc524c5bbcec668ea3e591b919ccdb725fd3e11d1ff0015d110d0951b6589b80e50856725b82e01fdf0b472c3fcb4619c744eeb70e4e8d66e600claims/registered/sim-crz-holdout-2026.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"graph_evidence":[{"concepts":"traffic volume or congestion | travel speed; traffic speed | ambulance travel time","direction":"none usable","n_findings":4,"summary":"System Public Graph variable sea…{ "id": "sim-crz-holdout-2026", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "The two links of the congestion-pricing simulator that are fitted to city data on non-holiday weekdays of 6 January to 23 Decem…sim-crz-holdout-2026{"name":"prereg/sim-crz-holdout-2026","sha":"0d9c9a4ae63c5a4c6deba654bf9a1c9cd5348d7a"}0.45—{"commit":"1819abd64c30d70ce34ba251873f41660e946536","committed_at":"2026-11-13T08:44:57-05:00"}——
split-temp-asthma-emsconfirmationIn New York City, within the same month and year, days in the cool half of the year (October to March) that are colder have more FDNY EMS dispatches for asthma, and the slope is more positive (or less…2026-11-12T22:49:54-050075d1a5bf8b737e3e3f6821d4e7524a010ad94f6fe2d39dbedae37ce7d9182fe7860b0029fa6d7da542248e5584eec97440a476877d95346b586f8d5b49f67e3eclaims/registered/split-temp-asthma-ems.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"GHC…{"alternatives":["Respiratory infections: cold spells coincide with influenza and RSV weeks; month fixed effects remove only part of this. Named, not separated.","Call-taking behaviour: on very cold o…{ "id": "split-temp-asthma-ems", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "In New York City, within the same month and year, days in the cool half of the year (October to March) that are colder have mo…split-temp-asthma-ems{"name":"prereg/split-temp-asthma-ems","sha":"15e54e1e7aab3891c95332349640c46aa5d01b95"}0.45Claude (split-literature study, graph discovery){"commit":"a588c84415ad5612b91449e102c1369458917cf1","committed_at":"2026-11-12T22:49:54-05:00"}——
split-temp-covid-growthconfirmationIn New York City, 2020 to 2025, weeks that follow warmer-than-normal weather for the time of year have slower growth of COVID-19 hospital admissions; and the raw correlation between daily temperature …2026-11-12T22:49:54-05003ff45bbe83195bc2c6a1fc71ca14c5abc4b7edc1b47df41313f4370635d5e824e53eb02b752d3858d51aa82e9eed4239033e685d5a4a7301c4f09b7b0a594cfeclaims/registered/split-temp-covid-growth.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"GHC…{"alternatives":["Behaviour: warm anomalies move people outdoors and cold ones indoors; this is part of the weather effect and is not separated from virus survival.","Variant waves: growth is dominate…{ "id": "split-temp-covid-growth", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "In New York City, 2020 to 2025, weeks that follow warmer-than-normal weather for the time of year have slower growth of COVI…split-temp-covid-growth{"name":"prereg/split-temp-covid-growth","sha":"2481beea34113c03c697e9dd8e02e6e2dd803446"}0.35Claude (split-literature study, graph discovery){"commit":"5443c2a34279deca1e9ec1a91e5c4ecb291a7832","committed_at":"2026-11-12T22:49:54-05:00"}——
stalled-421a-vesting-footingsconfirmationNew-building jobs that began foundation work in the six months before the 421-a vesting deadline of 15 June 2022 failed to reach a certificate of occupancy within 36 months more often than jobs that b…2026-11-13T11:55:23-05000ff6d1daae72533b4326615a6c4b725cd04e1dc2ef73c315fde3a3a2df7c1628e1f9ca0f68822b303fa1c8c0ef9fb88f58b1361a2d5d096f342d91338eaabafeclaims/registered/stalled-421a-vesting-footings.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"c","class_meaning":"a shared cache: the query was fetched for an earlier claim and holds this claim's outcome","classes":["c"…{"alternatives":["Interest-rate and cost shock of 2022-2023 affecting all jobs started in 2022 (D2 separates it partly; the 2023 cohort faces the same rates)","System change: 65% of the 2022 window is…{ "id": "stalled-421a-vesting-footings", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "New-building jobs that began foundation work in the six months before the 421-a vesting deadline of 15 June 2022 faile…stalled-421a-vesting-footings{"name":"prereg/stalled-421a-vesting-footings","sha":"ea9ff50ad9c60b3e9071ab8ff5f0b60e9bb98c75"}0.45claude-opus (stalled-construction agent), 13 Nov 2026{"commit":"ea9ff50ad9c60b3e9071ab8ff5f0b60e9bb98c75","committed_at":"2026-11-13T11:55:24-05:00"}——
stalled-flood-zone-startsconfirmationNew-building jobs on lots in the 2015 preliminary 1%-annual-chance floodplain fail to reach a certificate of occupancy within 36 months of their first foundation permit more often than jobs elsewhere …2026-11-13T11:59:11-05002904af8de8b282f1b3508d91dcd41b6ea9282ca7792838dc3e718b16b9de0f446faf7932b358bc751e403da266e859140706e368de7bfb400ab7a402932b004aclaims/registered/stalled-flood-zone-starts.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"c","class_meaning":"a shared cache: the query was fetched for an earlier claim and holds this claim's outcome","classes":["c"…{"alternatives":["Neighbourhood market: floodplain lots in Queens and Brooklyn are in Rockaway, Coney Island, Red Hook and Gowanus, where demand differs (borough stratification only partly removes it)…{ "id": "stalled-flood-zone-starts", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "New-building jobs on lots in the 2015 preliminary 1%-annual-chance floodplain fail to reach a certificate of occupancy wit…stalled-flood-zone-starts{"name":"prereg/stalled-flood-zone-starts","sha":"fc819e57bae93f53cc3bb1f65682af895a4a4512"}0.35claude-opus (stalled-construction agent), 13 Nov 2026{"commit":"fc819e57bae93f53cc3bb1f65682af895a4a4512","committed_at":"2026-11-13T11:59:11-05:00"}——
street-busway14-crosstown-detourconfirmationAfter the 14th Street busway began, weekday daytime yellow-taxi trips between the west and east sides of the 14th Street corridor became about 1.5% longer in metered distance relative to comparable cr…2026-11-13T12:05:53-050072caf4e33ca4292602d0dfb997db7de6f65d98be8663555c42622c212c1e95d476a9fb45db97e5ccdb5460a472c82362457f8588b34cfef02051ff49b73e1187claims/registered/street-busway14-crosstown-detour.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"b","class_meaning":"a design, power or calibration read, pre-period data, or metadata","classes":["b"],"early_sources":[{"cla…{"alternatives":["Year-to-year drift of the contrast between the 14th Street corridor and the control corridors (seen in the design run: +3.4% from 2017-18 to 2018-19 in the plain year-over-year DiD),…{ "id": "street-busway14-crosstown-detour", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "After the 14th Street busway began, weekday daytime yellow-taxi trips between the west and east sides of the 14th S…street-busway14-crosstown-detour{"name":"prereg/street-busway14-crosstown-detour","sha":"18e3f4b0d54e695287c540e884b2f3c9fce92ae9"}0.45Claude (agent, street-space task), 13 November 2026{"commit":"18e3f4b0d54e695287c540e884b2f3c9fce92ae9","committed_at":"2026-11-13T12:05:53-05:00"}——
street-busway14-crosstown-timeconflictAfter the 14th Street busway began on 3 October 2019, weekday daytime yellow-taxi trips between zones on the west and east sides of the 14th Street corridor lengthened by about 5% relative to comparab…2026-11-13T12:05:53-05007ce1f43da35120ec69043b550b2af31513667efa399735e6aaeb37cfb600b130805bd298133944dc22a5824f68906a9b14e0db8a15263a2b04da7008c02ad0b4claims/registered/street-busway14-crosstown-time.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"b","class_meaning":"a design, power or calibration read, pre-period data, or metadata","classes":["b"],"early_sources":[{"cla…{"alternatives":["Year-to-year drift of the contrast between the 14th Street corridor and the control corridors (seen in the design run: +3.4% from 2017-18 to 2018-19 in the plain year-over-year DiD),…{ "id": "street-busway14-crosstown-time", "kind": "conflict", "statement": "After the 14th Street busway began on 3 October 2019, weekday daytime yellow-taxi trips between zones on the west and eas…street-busway14-crosstown-time{"name":"prereg/street-busway14-crosstown-time","sha":"d865ceb299eae96b255e90dbb9a722ae20f50703"}0.35Claude (agent, street-space task), 13 November 2026{"commit":"d865ceb299eae96b255e90dbb9a722ae20f50703","committed_at":"2026-11-13T12:05:53-05:00"}——
street-busway14-fhv-north-southconfirmationOn high-volume for-hire trips (Uber, Lyft and others), weekday daytime trips between East Chelsea and Stuy Town or Gramercy (zones on both sides of Fifth Avenue north of 14th Street) lengthened by rou…2026-11-13T13:18:18-0500983488eaf0654b12927630f39477c6cc81d021550dc9f8e3ff80b38f049afe8dd5208d0ebff27a3d1f12ef335d04212fd31647e68e32807a0e373dabada9f13fclaims/registered/street-busway14-fhv-north-south.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"b","class_meaning":"a design, power or calibration read, pre-period data, or metadata","classes":["b"],"early_sources":[{"cla…{"alternatives":["FHV trips differ from taxi trips in purpose and are routed by apps (Waze-like routing may use side streets differently).","The FHV seasonal swing may differ from the yellow swing; th…{ "id": "street-busway14-fhv-north-south", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "On high-volume for-hire trips (Uber, Lyft and others), weekday daytime trips between East Chelsea and Stuy Town or G…street-busway14-fhv-north-south{"name":"prereg/street-busway14-fhv-north-south","sha":"0f85b3ad535a5ca0b118b088f50043bc41fec0d9"}0.45Claude (agent, street-space task), 13 November 2026{"commit":"0f85b3ad535a5ca0b118b088f50043bc41fec0d9","committed_at":"2026-11-13T13:18:18-05:00"}——
street-busway14-m14-speedconfirmationOn weekdays in October 2019 to February 2020 the M14A and M14D Select Bus Service ran at least 4% faster, relative to the other Manhattan bus routes, than in July to September 2019, when the SBS ran w…2026-11-13T13:12:22-05003a9ed05a54f81f1f92c8303f8aacbc11f9db8818bd5cd3d41c7e9ea99af36b37f76c3a97c3915dc42ec51cce34768d8d4c07df98e73a5ecf8003605356a16955claims/registered/street-busway14-m14-speed.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Seasonal differences between the M14 and other routes (the placebo spread covers typical ones).","SBS learning effects (riders using off-board fare more over time), which would conti…{ "id": "street-busway14-m14-speed", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "On weekdays in October 2019 to February 2020 the M14A and M14D Select Bus Service ran at least 4% faster, relative to the …street-busway14-m14-speed{"name":"prereg/street-busway14-m14-speed","sha":"f26cd61cc1781f85f63b3af5a1d1cf2af7824519"}0.75Claude (agent, street-space task), 13 November 2026{"commit":"f26cd61cc1781f85f63b3af5a1d1cf2af7824519","committed_at":"2026-11-13T13:12:22-05:00"}{"built_at":"2026-11-13T22:57:10-0500","checked_at":"2026-11-13T22:57:10-0500","decides":"support_if: DiD >= 4% and lower 95% limit above 0","deciding_number":"city_effect: percent change in M14A+M14D…—
street-busway14-ped-injuriesconfirmationIn the three years after the busway began (October 2019 to September 2022), crashes injuring or killing a pedestrian on 14th Street between Ninth and Third Avenues fell by about a third relative to 23…2026-11-13T13:12:24-0500363078ae117409fb2ab87c9e6fd8c7cde527b84d7b9638494bce82d468f264e40ddb9085a59f13225faf68a1b82c8e9d37700d8e0bf5313c2ff261f364ee362dclaims/registered/street-busway14-ped-injuries.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["The pandemic changed traffic and walking differently in Midtown (offices, theatres) and around 14th Street (residential, Union Square).","Other street changes on the control corridor…{ "id": "street-busway14-ped-injuries", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "In the three years after the busway began (October 2019 to September 2022), crashes injuring or killing a pedestrian on…street-busway14-ped-injuries{"name":"prereg/street-busway14-ped-injuries","sha":"f470dd587484f90b80954bfcbc08f25b85460638"}0.35Claude (agent, street-space task), 13 November 2026{"commit":"f470dd587484f90b80954bfcbc08f25b85460638","committed_at":"2026-11-13T13:12:25-05:00"}——
transfer-chicago-concordance-matrixconfirmationAcross Chicago's 77 community areas, pairs of an air pollution or traffic indicator with a health outcome agree with the sign of the System Public Graph's findings more often than the same kind of pai…2026-11-13T01:23:02-05007e47ca346696757000081b75e4c48e3e3f60b30dd99c37117791743c80c8e89fabfa2d925d297132ad37f71f0e735be00fcc82a97ae0b8c713546f6b2225c401claims/registered/transfer-chicago-concordance-matrix.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Measurement: a smooth regional PM2.5 or ozone surface ranks community areas by position in the region (a north-south gradient), so its correlation with outcomes may reflect geography…{ "id": "transfer-chicago-concordance-matrix", "kind": "confirmation", "transfer": { "from_city": "New York City", "to_city": "Chicago", "from_claim": "graph-concordance-matrix", "nyc_estim…transfer-chicago-concordance-matrix{"name":"prereg/transfer-chicago-concordance-matrix","sha":"2805fb30a1b67b36e4b1b9fcaa1642806867ebc5"}0.35Claude (round 5: Chicago concordance matrix){"commit":"499547cdfbeb5673f18fc44a3194c9db320b74a9","committed_at":"2026-11-13T01:23:02-05:00"}——
transfer-chicago-heat-shootingsconfirmationIn Chicago, the daily number of shooting incidents with a gunshot injury rises with the day's maximum temperature at Midway Airport by about the same proportion as in New York (IRR 1.146 per 5 C, 1.13…2026-11-12T22:32:24-0500ca1b588f239bd5617756830950b4483a5389fd658758ef4e8eb64ea50f98c3dabdfc64a56d196bdf43c3f58ca8129361cb99302d162ec1f009201687266b00eaclaims/registered/transfer-chicago-heat-shootings.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Different seasonal structure: Chicago's colder winters and larger seasonal range change how much of the temperature signal month terms absorb.","Different reporting: gunshot victimiz…{ "id": "transfer-chicago-heat-shootings", "kind": "confirmation", "transfer": { "from_city": "New York City", "to_city": "Chicago", "from_claim": "heat-shootings", "nyc_estimate": { "ir…transfer-chicago-heat-shootings{"name":"prereg/transfer-chicago-heat-shootings","sha":"8e6e3d32fee502a25f45a59b72e69b0a1f1b188a"}0.6Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"0166e873ca5225e9a222cf21ac9579087e466adb","committed_at":"2026-11-12T22:32:30-05:00"}——
transfer-chicago-hot-endconfirmationIn Chicago, as in New York, a daily proxy for people outdoors (Divvy bicycle trips) stops rising with maximum temperature between 27 and 33 C while shootings keep rising, and adding the proxy to the s…2026-11-12T23:46:43-0500c23b08942fa109d0d097c79a7fd3324b3eba128b5c80bee56f52743a940c17ed08cc7db8c6328da5904d1f6aeafacced92e6dad97c9f393dc7861dedc1894efeclaims/registered/transfer-chicago-hot-end.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"c","class_meaning":"a shared cache: the query was fetched for an earlier claim and holds this claim's outcome","classes":["c"…{"already_seen":"Chicago shootings and Midway temperature were fetched and analysed by transfer-chicago-heat-shootings. That study saw the linear rate ratio (1.131 per 5 C, 1.120 to 1.143) and eight l…{ "id": "transfer-chicago-hot-end", "kind": "confirmation", "transfer": { "from_city": "New York City", "to_city": "Chicago", "from_claim": "heat-mech-outdoors", "from_exploratory": "data/d…transfer-chicago-hot-end{"name":"prereg/transfer-chicago-hot-end","sha":"4e5e256d162bf19c6752b8648bef864fda45d76f"}0.15Claude (round 2 agent, hot-end transfer){"commit":"c9f6e418f61116768fc23f7233217516cedf4ce3","committed_at":"2026-11-12T23:46:43-05:00"}——
transfer-chicago-weekday-patternconfirmationIn the Chicago Loop, the Monday/Friday deficit in 'L' station entries, relative to Tuesday to Thursday, rose from 2019 to the 12 months to October 2026 by about as many percentage points as the New Yo…2026-11-12T22:32:24-0500c55ef3974a55bd7f5fdfd58d4e1bbd74bec3c683f17a12a649511aa8f167f890077abf1ca8e5b9674fdde425b2013e098e279e668855a94504dc953c5bf4fcadclaims/registered/transfer-chicago-weekday-pattern.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["A Monday/Friday deficit before 2020 that differs between the cities for institutional reasons (office hours, schedules, school calendars).","CTA service levels on Mondays and Fridays…{ "id": "transfer-chicago-weekday-pattern", "kind": "confirmation", "transfer": { "from_city": "New York City", "to_city": "Chicago", "from_claim": "transit-weekday-pattern", "nyc_estimate"…transfer-chicago-weekday-pattern{"name":"prereg/transfer-chicago-weekday-pattern","sha":"475b4d07a4e109b721896c27dd83065650bc51d7"}0.4Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"4bf91ba8418b21bca78ab89f656519074fb5cd12","committed_at":"2026-11-12T22:32:30-05:00"}——
transit-fhv-price-subwayconfirmationAfter the congestion surcharge on for-hire and taxi trips touching Manhattan south of 96th Street began on 2 February 2019, weekday subway entries at station complexes inside that area rose relative t…2026-11-12T20:19:15-050079b636c16f764a06c5582b66e9c873b9cbf72aa9c35ebb2479213c823050aac49571ea1608b845c09173602af82269a82bf86dc8b159852a149131cb53e85009claims/registered/transit-fhv-price-subway.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Differential subway service changes between the zone and the rest of the system in early 2019 against early 2018 (Subway Action Plan improvements, weekend and night work, station clo…{ "id": "transit-fhv-price-subway", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "After the congestion surcharge on for-hire and taxi trips touching Manhattan south of 96th Street began on 2 February 2019,…transit-fhv-price-subway{"name":"prereg/transit-fhv-price-subway","sha":"f179bce94542addecdf1cae577319a953da26a13"}0.08Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"f14bcec71c4c233890e084ca0e430119668f5bdb","committed_at":"2026-11-12T20:19:15-05:00"}——
transit-gtrain-substitutionconfirmationDuring the summer 2024 G train shutdown, daily Uber and Lyft pickups in taxi zones whose G-only stations had no train service rose relative to nearby Brooklyn and Queens zones without G stations, whic…2026-11-12T20:17:01-050096025ddce56d9130e4aa334661ce133aae2a586c0960aa8ae324b8ac3b718c589e13d6f7d76f1409163cafe148812ef2ea4698041b51a8a6268fb1c05815af3cclaims/registered/transit-gtrain-substitution.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"none","class_meaning":"the audit found no city-data source fetched before registration","classes":[],"early_sources":[]}{"alternatives":["Shuttle buses, walking to the L, 7, C, J and M, and bicycles (Citi Bike) absorb the displaced riders, so that a small or null effect does not show that ride-hail and the subway are u…{ "id": "transit-gtrain-substitution", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "During the summer 2024 G train shutdown, daily Uber and Lyft pickups in taxi zones whose G-only stations had no train se…transit-gtrain-substitution{"name":"prereg/transit-gtrain-substitution","sha":"43c88be7f53ed968cf48cf0c65d2d1a3f8da776d"}0.35Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"968e62133e2cd0b9c0461f0f6e9685d50e6a4ec8","committed_at":"2026-11-12T20:17:01-05:00"}——
transit-weekday-patternconfirmationIn the Manhattan central business district, weekday subway entries in the 12 months to October 2026 are about equal on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday and at least 8% lower on Monday and Friday, and t…2026-11-12T20:17:29-0500c6acdb46f40a0c32126b0b3be16c54694f5ad05f272ada7971f15a9dbed3b1404a36e5d840f2f3625eb81a6aee5d99ac00306353d4d574d0659a759971aef50cclaims/registered/transit-weekday-pattern.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"b","class_meaning":"a design, power or calibration read, pre-period data, or metadata","classes":["b"],"early_sources":[{"cla…{"alternatives":["A Monday/Friday deficit that existed before 2020 for reasons other than remote work (long weekends, compressed schedules, part-time work, school calendars); the 2019 baseline measure…{ "id": "transit-weekday-pattern", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "In the Manhattan central business district, weekday subway entries in the 12 months to October 2026 are about equal on Tuesd…transit-weekday-pattern{"name":"prereg/transit-weekday-pattern","sha":"aa186f15776434e6e8b3c27859df92325be1a596"}0.45Claude (agent), for Jeff Vernon{"commit":"b696a08229709cb4591912643fc500bc3a702402","committed_at":"2026-11-12T20:17:29-05:00"}——
turn-calming-displacementconfirmationLeft-turn traffic calming did not displace pedestrian injuries to the surrounding blocks: in the ring 50-200 m from treated intersections (excluding crashes within 40 m of any calming site), pedestria…2026-11-13T13:18:40-050023f15f06067ea1e3be4bfba5222b969e0251810ddd256882dbe7d04304618092c935b33f52fe5d8b10947e9976a6536fcf5d9c3ead689b45fb34482547e58c1aclaims/registered/turn-calming-displacement.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"sm2…{"alternatives":["Regression to the mean: DOT chooses sites after crash clusters (the design compares with sites DOT chose later, which were also chosen for crash history, but those were chosen later …{ "id": "turn-calming-displacement", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "Left-turn traffic calming did not displace pedestrian injuries to the surrounding blocks: in the ring 50-200 m from treate…turn-calming-displacement{"name":"prereg/turn-calming-displacement","sha":"85b40afe305542b98df35efa4e483d89628ec263"}0.5turn-restrictions agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon{"commit":"85b40afe305542b98df35efa4e483d89628ec263","committed_at":"2026-11-13T13:18:40-05:00"}——
turn-calming-leftturnconfirmationNYC DOT left-turn traffic calming reduced crashes involving a vehicle whose pre-crash manoeuvre was 'Making Left Turn' within 40 m of treated intersections in the two years after installation, relativ…2026-11-13T13:18:40-05006fd0c7580fe89c80cf806caf05e2198c55687cf790807f26b22f76298de7927a7406a97e18750e65e328dabd51d260c5cb854f041e02db31d0624f32d6b60aaeclaims/registered/turn-calming-leftturn.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"sm2…{"alternatives":["Regression to the mean: DOT chooses sites after crash clusters (the design compares with sites DOT chose later, which were also chosen for crash history, but those were chosen later …{ "id": "turn-calming-leftturn", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "NYC DOT left-turn traffic calming reduced crashes involving a vehicle whose pre-crash manoeuvre was 'Making Left Turn' within …turn-calming-leftturn{"name":"prereg/turn-calming-leftturn","sha":"85b40afe305542b98df35efa4e483d89628ec263"}0.45turn-restrictions agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon{"commit":"85b40afe305542b98df35efa4e483d89628ec263","committed_at":"2026-11-13T13:18:40-05:00"}——
turn-calming-pedconfirmationNYC DOT left-turn traffic calming (hardened centerlines, slow-turn wedges and related treatments) reduced pedestrians injured or killed within 40 m of treated intersections in the two years after inst…2026-11-13T13:18:40-05005941844b4bc2fd346ebb469eafa51c0dc44fca0f1ff247bc0086f3fba10debc239b6acbce398b1d1690b335c6426d6158313d314f24123594ea9c35548e4f647claims/registered/turn-calming-ped.jsontrue{"audit":"docs/lineage_audit.md; data/derived/lineage_audit.json","class":"a","class_meaning":"exposure or treatment only, not the outcome","classes":["a"],"early_sources":[{"class":"a","dataset":"sm2…{"alternatives":["Regression to the mean: DOT chooses sites after crash clusters (the design compares with sites DOT chose later, which were also chosen for crash history, but those were chosen later …{ "id": "turn-calming-ped", "kind": "confirmation", "statement": "NYC DOT left-turn traffic calming (hardened centerlines, slow-turn wedges and related treatments) reduced pedestrians injured or ki…turn-calming-ped{"name":"prereg/turn-calming-ped","sha":"85b40afe305542b98df35efa4e483d89628ec263"}0.35turn-restrictions agent (Claude Opus 5.5), for J. Vernon{"commit":"85b40afe305542b98df35efa4e483d89628ec263","committed_at":"2026-11-13T13:18:40-05:00"}{"built_at":"2026-11-13T23:18:28-0500","checked_at":"2026-11-13T23:18:28-0500","decides":"support_if: upper bound of the 95% interval of the ratio of ratios below 1.00","deciding_number":"city_effect:…—